IMPORTANT: This forum has now moved to http://howwhatwhy.com/forum/

Your username has not been migrated, therefore you will need to register an account on the new forum. Please read the 'Read Me First' post for information on registering and the move.

The forums and articles below are for reference and can not now be added to or modified. Please visit the new forum to continue discussion.


 Hot topics  ‡   ‡  Hot topics 
Machines >> Machines

Pages: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | (show all)
Rep
 

Reged: 08/09/03
Posts: 1176
Loc: Pine City, NY
Heater
      #262499 - 12/27/05 09:32 AM

What are your opinions about this heater?

http://www.biotechresearch.com/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=34_36&products_id=72&osCsid=3e66229f2faa035c7e2a879294b15ae0

I am mostly concerned with the cost of electric for the heat output generated. $1/day (their estimate) would probably save some money, and I would only use it when in the room. If this unit was used to heat a room at the bottom of a stairway, would the heat go up the stairway?

OK, now I'm going to the web for more fodder...

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: Rep] new
      #262500 - 12/27/05 10:04 AM

Quote:

What are your opinions about this heater?

http://www.biotechresearch.com/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=34_36&products_id=72&osCsid=3e66229f2faa035c7e2a879294b15ae0

I am mostly concerned with the cost of electric for the heat output generated. $1/day (their estimate) would probably save some money, and I would only use it when in the room. If this unit was used to heat a room at the bottom of a stairway, would the heat go up the stairway?



Hi Rep. The biggest complaint with any type of quartz heater is that they don't heat rooms all that well. They heat objects just fine, but unless you want to sit right in fron of it all day, opt for something else. This particular one I'm not familiar with, but a search revealed a bunch of complaints from folks on other forums, most saying just what I did, and just as many saying it was way overpriced. Every one of them said they would NOT recommend it to others. Here's just one reply. At $397.00, and for as slow as they DO heat things up, I think you could find a MUCH better source for your heat. I'm not a huge fan of portable electric heaters, but Honeywell has a really good one, and it's VERY safe with even minimal care. Click on the picture at this link for a close up. It's one of my favorites in this arena. They heat up quickly, and can be set for a specific temp, and can even be set to shut off after a set time.


Quote:

OK, now I'm going to the web for more fodder...



Check google results that appear to be bulliten boards for DIY or construction type sites. They typically have responses from actual users, not the folks trying to sell you their heater.
Al

--------------------
Common sense is not so common.
Voltaire





Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Phonedave
Count de Monet
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 6624
Loc: Northeast NJ - USA
Re: Heater [Re: Rep] new
      #262501 - 12/27/05 10:16 AM

Quote:

What are your opinions about this heater?

http://www.biotechresearch.com/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=34_36&products_id=72&osCsid=3e66229f2faa035c7e2a879294b15ae0

I am mostly concerned with the cost of electric for the heat output generated. $1/day (their estimate) would probably save some money, and I would only use it when in the room. If this unit was used to heat a room at the bottom of a stairway, would the heat go up the stairway?

OK, now I'm going to the web for more fodder...




$1 a day. Thats not cheap at all, at least to me. Even at $300/month for gas - which I have hit when prices are high and the weather is cold (and then I cry a lot ) that comes out to $10/day for my entire 3 bedroom 3 bath house. and additional $1 a day is another 10%, just for an electric heater.

Personaly, I am fond of the oil filled ones. I have one in my basement (in case anyone makes the connection, this means I have NOT got around to running the heat down there yet ) They fire up fairly quickly, and then provide a nice even heat, with very little cycyling. Mine has adjustable wattages and an adjustable thermostat.

-dave



--------------------
You're drunk again!
No, I'm just exhausted 'cause I've been up all night drinking.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: Phonedave] new
      #262503 - 12/27/05 10:34 AM

Quote:

$1 a day. Thats not cheap at all, at least to me. Even at $300/month for gas - which I have hit when prices are high and the weather is cold (and then I cry a lot ) that comes out to $10/day for my entire 3 bedroom 3 bath house. and additional $1 a day is another 10%, just for an electric heater.

Personaly, I am fond of the oil filled ones. I have one in my basement (in case anyone makes the connection, this means I have NOT got around to running the heat down there yet )




Quote:

They fire up fairly quickly, and then provide a nice even heat, with very little cycyling. Mine has adjustable wattages and an adjustable thermostat.

-dave



Also a very good heater, though I'd suggest getting feedback on any particular type before buying one. They are not all created equal, but the good ones ARE one of the best ways to go for temporary heating sources. Got a particular model you happen to be fond of Dave? The reason I say this is because I've seen a couple of the upright models (off brands) come back to the Depot, "slightly burned". Melted actually, though again, I DO happen to like that style with the better brands. As you said, very even heat, and a nice long off cycle due to the oil continuing to radiate heat long after the resistance heaters have gone cold.
Al

--------------------
Common sense is not so common.
Voltaire





Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Rep
 

Reged: 08/09/03
Posts: 1176
Loc: Pine City, NY
Re: Heater [Re: Rep] new
      #262524 - 12/27/05 08:32 PM

Thanks, Dave and AL for the help. Based on your comments and links, it looks like it would not meet our expectations on heat and savings.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Junkman462
Member
 

Reged: 08/12/03
Posts: 177
Loc: Northeast US
Re: Heater [Re: Rep] new
      #262532 - 12/27/05 10:46 PM

Beware of that heater. It's extremely overpriced, and the advertising is misleading and incomplete. From the information supplied, it's an electric heater that uses a quartz heating element to generate heat, and is housed inside a cabinet that does not get overly hot. They don't state whether it uses a fan to circulate hot air around the room, although I suspect it does, since that would aid in keeping the cabinet cool. The fact that the outside of the cabinet stays relatively cool is a plus, since burns and fires can indeed occur from electric heaters that have hot outer surfaces, or are placed too close to combustible materials. Also, fires can occur when clothing and sheets are draped over heaters by accident.
The advertising for the EdenPure does not state the wattage or BTU rating, which is suspicious. They apparently don't want potential buyers to comparison shop based on the wattage rating and price. However, since it does plug into a "110" volt household circuit, the power consumption ( and heat output) is probably no more than 1500 watts , which puts the amperage draw at about 13 amps , (assuming an actual 117 volt circuit.) Most household 110 volt devices draw no more than about 13 amps, since more current will start blowing fuses and tripping circuit breakers. At $397, that's a very expensive 1500 watt electric heater, since other types are priced between $20 and $65 . There are other electric heaters that stay relatively cool on the outside; small units with ceramic heating elements and fans stay cool, and will only overheat if the air flow is blocked by furniture placed too closely, or by clothing draped over the unit. All electric heaters have thermostats that should keep them from overheating, although you have to trust that the thermostat will function quickly and reliably.
The type of heating element is actually not significant for a convection heater, whether it's a Ni-Cad hot wire, ceramic, or quartz. ( For a purely radiant spot heater, the quartz heating elements do work well.) All electric room heaters are essentially 100% efficient ,although radiant heaters are best for spot heating, and convection heaters, with or without fans, are better for room or area heating. (Convection heating means that warm air circulates around the room, either by a fan or by hot air rising without a fan.)
The advertising for the EdenPURE also implies that their heater alone does not reduce room humidity, does not use up room oxygen, and does not generate carbon monoxide. Actually, no electric room heater does any of those things. Room absolute humidity is not affected by a heater, but relative humidity (dependent on air temperature) will be reduced by all heaters. No electric heater uses up room oxygen, as can propane,natural gas, or kerosene heaters that draw their combustion air from the room. No electric heaters generate carbon monoxide, as can propane, natural gas, or kerosene heaters that are not vented with a chimney to the outside.
So, for nearly $400, you're not getting anything special with the EdenPURE. I use electric oil filled radiators for keeping small areas warmer than the rest of my house. They're a bit bulkier than most other electric heaters, but they're completely silent, and the surface temperature stays low enough to avoid burns and fires. They should not be covered with clothing or other objects, however, since that may cause them to overheat. A radiator unit with 600, 900, and 1500 watt settings costs about $60. A ceramic element heater with a fan of the same wattage rating is priced at about $20 to $30.

--------------------
A treasure of trivia .

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Kyle
Should be doing something else
 

Reged: 07/27/03
Posts: 2346
Loc: Los Angeles
Re: Heater [Re: Rep] new
      #262536 - 12/28/05 02:31 AM

Quote:

What are your opinions about this heater?

http://www.biotechresearch.com/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=34_36&products_id=72&osCsid=3e66229f2faa035c7e2a879294b15ae0

I am mostly concerned with the cost of electric for the heat output generated. $1/day (their estimate) would probably save some money, and I would only use it when in the room. If this unit was used to heat a room at the bottom of a stairway, would the heat go up the stairway?

OK, now I'm going to the web for more fodder...



I'm going to chime in a bit late here. Just by looking at the other products they offer, I wouldn't buy anything from this catalog.


--------------------
Kyle

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: Junkman462] new
      #262556 - 12/28/05 09:34 AM

Including Kyle's post, that makes it 4 for 4 Rep. If this stays up long enough, I'm sure it will go to somwhere around 10 for 10 that advise to avoid the quartz heaters. I've never met ANYONE who had something GOOD to say about them, ... well, other than their own advertising people, who probably don't own them either.
Al

--------------------
Common sense is not so common.
Voltaire





Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Phonedave
Count de Monet
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 6624
Loc: Northeast NJ - USA
Re: Heater [Re: GrandfatherClock] new
      #262561 - 12/28/05 12:03 PM

Quote:

Got a particular model you happen to be fond of Dave?





DeLonghi - 1500 W

Not sure where it came from. I've had it for 4 years or so with no problems. I think I inherited it, now that I think about it.

-dave

--------------------
You're drunk again!
No, I'm just exhausted 'cause I've been up all night drinking.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Rep
 

Reged: 08/09/03
Posts: 1176
Loc: Pine City, NY
Re: Heater [Re: Junkman462] new
      #262587 - 12/28/05 07:14 PM

Wow, this is the longest response I have ever received, and only one response (not on HWW, just an email) has had more information - when I asked a server guru about the + & - 's of one vs two CPU's on a server. Thank you JM, I appreciate all the info.

Thanks to the others who responded as well. Looks like they don't make a sale.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: Junkman462] new
      #263114 - 01/05/06 03:49 PM

It's taken me awhile to get to this, but I think it's well worth mentioning that you've done a great job with this reply JM. Well done.
Al

--------------------
Happy return to an arbitrarily chosen starting point in the orbit about our gravitational enslaver.
Swansont




Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
marc13
Member
 

Reged: 01/06/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: Rep] new
      #263188 - 01/06/06 10:12 AM

Let me offer my thinking on the edenpure heater as I sit, somewhat cold, in my office trying to decide whether or not to buy one. As I understand this, a quartz infrared heater is good at heating objects rather than the air. This can keep a person relatively warm in a cool room if they stay seated or at least within the arc of the infrared lamp. That makes it relatively more efficient than heating the entire space around them, even if the cost/btu looks unfavorable.

The Edenpure seems to be a hybrid system. It uses an infrared lamp to heat a copper heat-exchanger. That would make it less efficient that using the infrared to heat you directly, but potentially more efficient in heating the entire room, because the infrared is (might be?) more efficient than oil or gas in heating the heat-exchanger.

If the room has relatively high humidity, this effect would be enhanced by the heat carrying capacity of the humidity (I just stepped over the bounds of what I think I understand).

As an investment, the Edenpure also has the advantage of any portable heat source in that it is portable. So I'm still a little skeptical, but still considering it. Like virtually all technologies, but might not be the best for all applications, but it might be the best for some.

I'd appreciate any corrections on my thinking or understanding of thermodynamics. Thanks

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: marc13] new
      #263228 - 01/06/06 05:12 PM

Quote:

Let me offer my thinking on the edenpure heater as I sit, somewhat cold, in my office trying to decide whether or not to buy one. As I understand this, a quartz infrared heater is good at heating objects rather than the air. This can keep a person relatively warm in a cool room if they stay seated or at least within the arc of the infrared lamp. That makes it relatively more efficient than heating the entire space around them, even if the cost/btu looks unfavorable.



Welcome to the forums marc13.
Did you notice that they don't give a BTU rating, or a wattage rating? Your assumptions about quartz heaters are correct, but infrared I'm not sure of. I haven't found much about that type, but do take notice of what some of us have suggested as alternates to this thing. In the sites I visited from other boards, I didn't see even one post recommending them (any style). The edenpure in EVERY case was concidered to be highly overpriced and very INefficient. JM ( Junkman462 summed it up very well, have a look.

Quote:

The Edenpure seems to be a hybrid system. It uses an infrared lamp to heat a copper heat-exchanger. That would make it less efficient that using the infrared to heat you directly, but potentially more efficient in heating the entire room, because the infrared is (might be?) more efficient than oil or gas in heating the heat-exchanger.



May I ask where you found this information? I've looked all over the place and couldn't find anything more than the manufacturers *claims. Nothing about copper heat exchanger.

Quote:

If the room has relatively high humidity, this effect would be enhanced by the heat carrying capacity of the humidity (I just stepped over the bounds of what I think I understand).



But from what I understand, it doesn't heat the room, just objects it's pointed at.

Quote:

As an investment, the Edenpure also has the advantage of any portable heat source in that it is portable. So I'm still a little skeptical, but still considering it. Like virtually all technologies, but might not be the best for all applications, but it might be the best for some.



At that price, I seriously doubt it.

Quote:

I'd appreciate any corrections on my thinking or understanding of thermodynamics. Thanks



Sounds like you have the jist of it, though I WILL bow to MANY others here.
Al

--------------------
Happy return to an arbitrarily chosen starting point in the orbit about our gravitational enslaver.
Swansont




Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Ted
The Other Old Geezer
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 2994
Loc: SE USA
Re: Heater [Re: Junkman462] new
      #263442 - 01/09/06 06:30 AM

Quote:

. . . . At $397, that's a very expensive 1500 watt electric heater . . . .


I was just thinking the same thing, Junkman.
1500 watts is about 5200 BTU. (That's what's on the label of a ceramic 'cube' heater I have under a desk at work.)
Just for comparison - most hair dryers are about 1500 watts.

--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."--H.L.Mencken
I suspect so, H.L.heh heh

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
philalethes
Member
 

Reged: 01/14/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: marc13] new
      #263939 - 01/14/06 08:22 PM

I install quite a few ventless propane heaters. They come in two flavors, blue flame, and an orange glow ceramic block radiant type.

Both are propane flame, but the orange block are supposed to heat the objects, while the blue flame heat the air.

When sitting even in front of the orange block "object heater" type, I notice that the room goes instantly cold (and so do I) when it goes off. Whereas the blue flame remains toasty.

I don't know if I can extrapolate from one to the other, but anything that purports to heat the objects and not the room is NOT recommended by me.

Glad to find this thread. I just got the Edenpure advert in the mail.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Ted
The Other Old Geezer
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 2994
Loc: SE USA
Re: Heater [Re: philalethes] new
      #263969 - 01/14/06 11:41 PM

Hi philalethes.
Welcome to the HWW Forums.

--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."--H.L.Mencken
I suspect so, H.L.heh heh

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GoBears
Member
 

Reged: 01/19/06
Posts: 3
Re: Heater [Re: marc13] new
      #264604 - 01/19/06 01:26 PM

Have you looke at an infrared bulb unit like the Portable Furnace? The air-flow from cool to warm seems a lot more stream-lined than the quartz heaters. Thoughts?

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: GoBears] new
      #264607 - 01/19/06 02:20 PM

Quote:

Thoughts?



Hi there Bears fan. Chicago your hometown? Welcome to the forums!
Interesting suggestion, and one I hadn't thought of. For a single room you don't want to heat on a regular basis, that sounds like a pretty good solution. A 1500W infrared furnace will do somewhere in the 800sq ft range, and might work out both hunky and dory. At about $600, it too is quite expensive, but the output heat is miles ahead of Edenpure's. This *could* be a good way for renters to go as well, since it IS portable, and would fit quite nicely in even a very compact car. At $600 though, I still have to wonder if it's even NEAR worth the price when an oil filled or a resistance style heater are so much less expensive, yet work just about as well. You did ask for "thoughts".
Al


--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire




Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Rick HarrisModerator
I'm confused.
 

Reged: 02/22/03
Posts: 6074
Loc: UK
Re: Heater [Re: Rep] new
      #264614 - 01/19/06 04:04 PM

In any heater - particularly an electric heater you need to have efficiency in operation - the fuel is relatively costly and even though the heat source is readily control it rarely is.

One of the best i have seen is the range of ceramic heaters that adjust the heat output according to the temperature difference. So that when the room is cold the heat output is high 9and so is the cost) but as the room heats up towards the required temperature the heat output is lowered to keep the temperature constant.

In effect this avoids the rush created by standard heaters that are just on or off allowing the room to cool too far before switching on the heat at full blast to restore the heat lost.

--------------------
I woke up today! - WOW!

Richard


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GoBears
Member
 

Reged: 01/19/06
Posts: 3
Re: Heater [Re: GrandfatherClock] new
      #264692 - 01/20/06 09:40 AM

By "Bears" I meant the University of California, Berkeley, commonly referred to as "Cal" (finished #25 this year!). Thanks for the help!

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
lconn
Member
 

Reged: 01/21/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: Rep] new
      #264877 - 01/21/06 07:38 PM

I bought the model 500, supposed to heat 500 sq. ft. Won't heat 240. Am returning it. Consider it a complete fraud!

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: lconn] new
      #264885 - 01/21/06 08:44 PM

Quote:

I bought the model 500, supposed to heat 500 sq. ft. Won't heat 240. Am returning it. Consider it a complete fraud!



Hi Iconn, and welcome to the forums. Sorry to hear that, but now you know where to get some information about just about any subject, and likely make some friends along the way. I hope you stick around and enjoy this place.
Al


--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire




Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GoBears
Member
 

Reged: 01/19/06
Posts: 3
Re: Heater [Re: lconn] new
      #265018 - 01/23/06 12:55 PM

Was that an eden pure?

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
CAM
Member
 

Reged: 02/02/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: GoBears] new
      #265987 - 02/02/06 12:41 PM

Quote:

Was that an eden pure?




This heater is just a big scam!!!

Go to: http://www.clarkpublicutilities.com/Residential/TheEnergyAdviser/Archives2006/06_01_15

and most likely many other sites on the net (I did a Google search on: EdenPURE™ Quartz Infrared Portable Heater) to see how much these people are scamming the public. All they do is create a earthy type sounding name and make lots of claims they can't prove; sell it with a money back guarantee, and they know from other past scam products that only a certain small percentage of customers will ever send it back.

Have people thought about the cost or availability of the infrared heating bulbs in these units when they burn out? Or as to how rugged these are? Bulbs in a portable unit, getting bumped, dropped, etc., equals short lifespan.

If people want to save money, there are many ways to be more efficient with heating as well as lighting. Putting plastic sheeting over the interior of windows. Also replacing all incandescent bulbs with compact fluorescent bulbs for lighting. Many dollars can be saved using common sense methods of conserving heat and electric.

Gotta go now as I've got a friend who is ready to purchase one of these magic, new age, cosmic heating units that I need to try to stop now.

Hope this helped folks clear up the confusion a bit.

Be well, and keep warm.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
madurkin
Member
 

Reged: 02/12/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: CAM] new
      #267098 - 02/12/06 11:28 AM

I have never signed up to a chatline before (I presume that's what this is). I found it by putting "edenpure" in google. I was looking for some info on the space heater after seeing an ad in my newspaper. I just had to sign up to thank you all for posting this good info on it. I have since decided to keep my small space heaters as they are doing a fine job. I have just been concerned with the safety issue of them. I think they will be fine as long as they are not near drapes or newspapers, etc. I want to especially thank this person who posted the url for the clarkpublicutilities site. That was the one that stopped me dead in my tracks to purchasing a edenpure spaceheater. Thanks.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Rick HarrisModerator
I'm confused.
 

Reged: 02/22/03
Posts: 6074
Loc: UK
Re: Heater [Re: madurkin] new
      #267105 - 02/12/06 12:28 PM

Quote:

I have never signed up to a chatline before (I presume that's what this is). I found it by putting "edenpure" in google. I was looking for some info on the space heater after seeing an ad in my newspaper. I just had to sign up to thank you all for posting this good info on it. I have since decided to keep my small space heaters as they are doing a fine job. I have just been concerned with the safety issue of them. I think they will be fine as long as they are not near drapes or newspapers, etc. I want to especially thank this person who posted the url for the clarkpublicutilities site. That was the one that stopped me dead in my tracks to purchasing a edenpure spaceheater. Thanks.




Aggggg!!! THIS IS A COMMUNITY OK I will drop the capitals-now - We are a collection of like minded folk who love technology - Not just for it's own sake but for what we can do with it or how it works. Technically we are a forum.

See the FAQ for history -

But that aside, welcome to our band of technological heroes and thanks for the thanks!.





--------------------
I woke up today! - WOW!

Richard


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
mred
Member
 

Reged: 10/06/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: Rep] new
      #286333 - 10/06/06 02:01 PM

I saw the add from Paul Harvey and found a heater with the same specs at Menards for $88. It does a great job on a 14x27 sunroom all winter with very few days that it can not keep up. It has a thermostat and 2 heat setting. I have always heated with 2 cube ceramic heaters and they were just adequite. So far I am happy. It looks like a flat screen TV and it heats up a copper sheet which radiates the heat to the room. No fan but you can feel the heat coomming off the front of the unit. Ed

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
garymurch
Member
 

Reged: 10/06/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: mred] new
      #286354 - 10/06/06 10:10 PM

Last year about this time I ordered a Suntwin heater, which is made by Edenpure and is the same heater but with a different cabinet.This heater is made in Vietnam.I was looking forward to getting it after hearing all the advertisements of how great a job it does.I had to wait a long time for it supposedly, because so many people were buying them,it caused a back order situation.I finally got the thing after waiting a couple of months.After all the waiting, I put it in our 9x12 family room which is only heated with one register and gets pretty chilly on cold winter days.I followed the directions on it and let it run for two days and I was totally disappointed in it.I packed it back up and sent it back.It took another couple of months to get my charge card credited for the full amount of the heater.I can't believe that they are still advertising these heaters that don't do what they claim they do.Please take it from me and don't waste your hard earned money on this overpriced scam.I am back to using my small ceramic heater in the room, which heats it a lot better than the Suntwin did.I hope this will help anyone who may be contemplating on getting one of these heaters.I learned the hard way. Gary

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
ColdDog
Member
 

Reged: 10/13/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: mred] new
      #286762 - 10/14/06 01:33 AM

Hey, Ed...what was the brand and model of the $88 heater from Menards? Can you tell a little more about it. What are you setting it at, and what are the outside temps, and the effect on your electric bill? I'd sure be willing to pay $88 for a heater like EdenPure advertises.

I am trying to heat a 250sq ft (25x10) sunporch to about 60 degrees this winter. I had a 1500 watt Holmes oil-filled heater, $40-something from Walmart that I bought last year (used in small bedroom last winter), but it was clearly struggling to keep up in the large space, but I thought it was safe to use because there is no flame. The porch was smoky this morning...heat and/or flame scorched the face plate...guess we're lucky the house didn't burn down. The radio pugged into the same outlet was completely unaffected (electricity never flickered), and the outlet is working fine. It was just the heater that fried. I saw the ad for EdenPure in the paper this morning, and was pretty interested since it "cannot start a fire". I'm not seeing a bad review on the better business website...they are BBB members. It only lists 57 complaints in 36 months. I would think there would be more complaints if the heater didn't work as promised. Yeah, it is pricey, but it's not the only brand at those prices, and after last night, it seems like it might be worth it.

I work a lot, and can't always be home to baby-sit a heater, and I don't want to worry about propane or kerosene, etc, starting a fire or asphyxiating my pets.

I read that, on average, you should figure 10 watts per sq ft to heat, so I'd need 2500+ watts output to heat the space. That's hard to find in a standard 110 plug electrical unit. I really don't want to wire in another outlet, and I'd rather not put two units in, but I might have to.

I'm open to suggestions!

Ed, hope to hear from you!

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
greybeard
Member
 

Reged: 07/24/03
Posts: 1988
Loc: Renton, WA
Re: Heater [Re: Rep] new
      #286766 - 10/14/06 06:34 AM

WOW! That's a lot of new members in one thread! They must be doing some serious advertising, if that many people are looking into it!
They do mention A BTU rating; 5000 and 2300. And it comes in 3 models...: the 1000 and the 500. And the list of features...! Wow! A genuine whopping 5.5 ft 14 gauge cord! And it contains Honeywell componenets (doesn't say it's made with them...). And a real plus; Made in factories throughout Asia! (it doesn't get better than that, does it?)
About the only thing missing is: "And if you order in the next 10 minutes you can get a second unit for only $1 more (plus shipping and handling). Operators are standing by"

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
bman
Member
 

Reged: 10/15/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: GrandfatherClock] new
      #286814 - 10/15/06 08:31 AM

Hi all,
My first time on the site but looks very informative. I have been looking for a heater to tackle my 400 sq ft basement. Have tried alot and nothing seems to work. Was looking into the Edenpure but couldn't find any info on it other than the website itself. I did find another heater this morning. www.reduceenergybills.com
Called the portable furnace. Little expensive but I found more info on it than the Edenpure. Also has replaceable lamps that the edenpure does not.
Any help or info would be appreciated. Just want something to heat my room.
Thanks

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Ted
The Other Old Geezer
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 2994
Loc: SE USA
Re: Heater [Re: bman] new
      #286816 - 10/15/06 10:26 AM

Hey Folks - ya just gotta read through this advertisement!!
It's some of the best advertising fluff I've seen in a while.
Whoever wrote it has surely kissed the Blarney Stone.
heh heh heh
Now, leaving that aside -

Hi Bman.
Welcome to the HWW Forums.

That is another rip-off.
It's attractively packaged and well written, but it's a rip-off.
It's basically four spot lights, in a wood box - with a very small fan and a thermostat.

From their Advertising:
"Uses less energy than a coffee maker"
Well, it will also produce less heating than a coffee maker. How well would a coffee maker heat your basement?
Think about it.

Also, from that ad:
"How much power does the Portable Furnace draw?
The Portable Furnace uses 1500 watts."


1500 Watts is equavalent to about 5200 BTU - the same as an el-cheapo hair drier from any dollar store.
1500 watts is 1500 watts whether you pay $30 at WalMart or $500 for this thing.

All these plug-in heaters are about 1500 watts, regardless of the physical size, bells and whistles, geegaws and do-dads, wood veneer and all the rest. That's all you can draw from a typical 15 amp wall circuit without tripping the breaker. None of these will provide adequate heating capacity for 400 sqft with a typical 8 ft ceiling.

You will get the same result with a 1500 watt, $30 cube heater from WalMart. They make pretty good foot warmers under a desk.

Here is a heating requiremet calculator that will help you determine how much heating capacity you will actually need.
I'm guessing you will need about 30,000 BTU capacity.

--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."--H.L.Mencken
I suspect so, H.L.heh heh

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: bman] new
      #286820 - 10/15/06 10:50 AM

Quote:

Hi all,
My first time on the site but looks very informative. I have been looking for a heater to tackle my 400 sq ft basement. Have tried alot and nothing seems to work. Was looking into the Edenpure but couldn't find any info on it other than the website itself. I did find another heater this morning. www.reduceenergybills.com
Called the portable furnace. Little expensive but I found more info on it than the Edenpure. Also has replaceable lamps that the edenpure does not.
Any help or info would be appreciated. Just want something to heat my room.
Thanks



My first question would be who makes it? I can't find a single reference to the manufacturer, hence, there isn't much I can do to check out their claims. Can you hear the needle on the sceptical meter hitting the top end yet?
Hi bman. The unit is rated at 1500 watts, and *appears* to use 4 common heat lamps to produce the heat. This unit also uses 1500 watts and would be a reasonable alternative that HAS a proven track record. I'm also fond of a few of the units Phonedave and a few others have mentioned, but even more of a fan of a permanently installed 220v baseboard unit with the T-stat wall mounted. The one you linked to is $499.00. The honeywell is well under $100.00, as would be a permanent 220v system. I'm NOT saying the one you linked to is not a good heater. It's just that I'm VERY leary of something I can find no information about other than *claims* by an unspecified manufacturer.
Al

--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire
Smileys



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: Ted] new
      #286821 - 10/15/06 10:53 AM

Ted, my man!! I see you beat me to it! Yup. Lots of *claims* and some nice packaging, buuutt..... $499.00? Wowzers!!
Al

--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire
Smileys



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Ted
The Other Old Geezer
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 2994
Loc: SE USA
Re: Heater [Re: GrandfatherClock] new
      #286822 - 10/15/06 11:01 AM

Hey ClockHopper!!

Is that some great advertising fluff, or what?heh heh heh

Yeah, $499 is kinda steep for 1500 watts.
You could get 16 'cubes' from WalMart for $499 - and have about 85000 btu capacity.

--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."--H.L.Mencken
I suspect so, H.L.heh heh

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: Ted] new
      #286823 - 10/15/06 11:13 AM

Quote:

Hey ClockHopper!!

Is that some great advertising fluff, or what?:Dheh heh heh



Ya have to give them credit for that!, Whoever *they* are.

Quote:

Yeah, $499 is kinda steep for 1500 watts.
You could get 16 'cubes' from WalMart for $499 - and have about 85000 btu capacity.



Of course an upgrade of the electrical system may be necessary to run them all. Almost 82,000 BTU. Just your average basement requirement.
Al


--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire
Smileys



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Patrick_
a child grown old
 

Reged: 08/15/03
Posts: 3015
Loc: Apex, NC
Re: Heater [Re: Ted] new
      #286826 - 10/15/06 01:09 PM

Quote:

It's attractively packaged and well written, but it's a rip-off.
It's basically four spot lights, in a wood box - with a very small fan and a thermostat.




Yeah, it honestly looks like some kid's science project. It probably isnt much more than some guys science project.

--------------------
WWFSMD

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Ted
The Other Old Geezer
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 2994
Loc: SE USA
Re: Heater [Re: GrandfatherClock] new
      #286829 - 10/15/06 02:12 PM

Quote:

. . . . upgrade of the electrical system . . . .


Yeah, that's true.
15 or 16 of those 'cubes' - jeez, you'd need about a 250 amp supply at 117 VAC.

Well . . . . eight or ten of 'em would probably have the capacity for a 1600 cu ft space. Still, that's about 150 amps at 117 VAC.

Ya know, those ceramic elements seem to be pretty tough. I inadvertantly wired one of those cubes across both hot feeds in a meter base once upon a time.
I was tent camping at the hunting club I belong to and it turned kinda cold that night.
The cube heater is part of the 'normal junk' that I keep in the old Datsun truck - my rolling storage shed.
There was an old power pole with a meter base nearby. Turned out the thing was hot, so I used a couple of heavy duty 'clip leads' and some electrical tape and bootlegged onto it.
About an hour later I realized that little heater was working too well and the fan was running faster than it should and realized what I'd done and went out and moved one of the clips over to the neutral.
I've still got that little heater and it still works just fine.


--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."--H.L.Mencken
I suspect so, H.L.heh heh

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
dabac
contrary consumer
 

Reged: 08/04/03
Posts: 1748
Loc: Stockholm, Sweden, Northern Europe
Re: Heater [Re: ColdDog] new
      #286887 - 10/16/06 05:45 AM

Quote:

... I had a 1500 watt Holmes oil-filled heater,



Oil-filled, or oil consuming?
If it's oil-filled, then it's basically an electric heater not that different from the ceramic ones but with oil as ballast. The large area of the oil reservoir lets you get away with a lower surface temperature, while the larger mass acts as a buffer when the heater cycles on and off.

Quote:

... I thought it was safe to use because there is no flame.



If it's oil-consuming, then there is some sort of combustion going on, even if it's catalytic. And a combustion process should ALWAYS be monitored either through technology or manually.

Quote:

The porch was smoky this morning...heat and/or flame scorched the face plate...




Had a quick google, apparently it's only oil-filled - you had a serious malfunction in that unit and that really shouldn't happen. Bring it back to the dealer and see what they say.
I run three units of similar function in my garage and haven't had any trouble. The local Scouts house is also heated solely by those, around a dozen of them. One has sprung a leak and got discarded, that's all.

Quote:

... The radio pugged into the same outlet was completely unaffected (electricity never flickered), and the outlet is working fine.



How one piece of equipment reacted can be a very poor indicator of how another piece of equipment would react. Radios for the most part are basically low voltage designs, they all have a considerable amount of power conditioner circuitry in them. Try pulling the plug while the radio is playing and you are quite likely to have a couple of sceonds of noise before the radio realizes that the feed is broken. Not all machines are so forgiving.
Quote:

..since it "cannot start a fire".


If you had a malfunction of the same order of magnitude in an edenpure as the one you had in your Holmes it would be about as likely to start a fire. Anything connected to the mains has the potential to start a fire, if it develops a short/poor connection at the most inappropiate place.

Quote:

I'm not seeing a bad review on the better business website...




But BBB is more about the performance of the company than the performance of the product, aren't they? Then a company could stand well in the eyes of BBB if they sell poor products as long as they're good about receiving them back and giving out refunds.

Besides, if you buy something that's obviously advertised too good to be true, then not all people would readily admit that they've been conned.


Quote:

after last night, it seems like it might be worth it.




Your Holmes had a catastrophic failure, a heater like that shouldn't fail like that. And it's quite hard to protect against catastrophic failures.
If you want a system that absolutely won't be able to cause damage to your house even in case of a catastrophic failure then I can't think of anything else than a boiler in a garden shed and piping to carry hot water to radiators inside your house.

Quote:

I work a lot, and can't always be home to baby-sit a heater,


A heater like that, you shouldn't have to.

Quote:

I read that, on average, you should figure 10 watts per sq ft to heat,



Average for what? You need to factor in how well insulated your house is and the climate zone you're in to begin with. Then there is the question of how warm you want it to be, what your ventilation is like, how the room is used and so on.

10 W/Sq ft would be sufficient to provide all heating for living quarters in a rather poorly insulated house in my climate zone. For a newer(better insulated) building and maybe allowing for a few appliances in the room half of that would be sufficient.

Quote:

I really don't want to wire in another outlet, and I'd rather not put two units in, but I might have to.



If you're talking electrical heating is very much related to how many amps you push through the heater, and if you can't get enough amps from one outlet then there's not much else to do.
Quote:

I'm open to suggestions!




If bringing heat in is difficult, then why not have a look at what can be done to keep it from escaping? Check seals at doors and windows, think about replacing windows or adding insulation. Maybe an air-to-air heat exchanger? The through-the-wall type are getting better and better these days. Price is dropping too.



--------------------
Unpleasant truth of the day - You're unique, but that doesn't make you special.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
bassman
Member
 

Reged: 10/17/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: GrandfatherClock] new
      #287040 - 10/17/06 04:17 PM

I have one of these and have some info.

1) The company "Portable Furnace" is in Winnipeg, Canada. They have a website www.portablefurnace.com. Also, for what it's worth mine heats my basement great (around 300 sq. ft.). It uses infrared bulbs that are 375 watts each. The way it works (so they tell me) is the air when heated is forced through a heat exchanger, like a furnace, and a fan blows it out. The big difference I like, rather than space heaters, is that my kids can play around it without knocking it over and/or burning them or my carpet. I shelled out some bucks for this so maybe I'm biased. It works for me and lives up to claims, at least so far. Thoughts?

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: bassman] new
      #287046 - 10/17/06 05:05 PM

Quote:

I have one of these and have some info.

1) The company "Portable Furnace" is in Winnipeg, Canada. They have a website www.portablefurnace.com. Also, for what it's worth mine heats my basement great (around 300 sq. ft.). It uses infrared bulbs that are 375 watts each. The way it works (so they tell me) is the air when heated is forced through a heat exchanger, like a furnace, and a fan blows it out. The big difference I like, rather than space heaters, is that my kids can play around it without knocking it over and/or burning them or my carpet. I shelled out some bucks for this so maybe I'm biased. It works for me and lives up to claims, at least so far. Thoughts?



Hi bassman. Thoughts? Just one (or two). I figured it would heat just fine, and as Ted mentioned, 1500 watts is 1500 watts no mater how you sclice it, but the price was *up there*. The upside is a decent looking cabinet that doesn't get hot, so as you mentioned, the kids remain safe. Another downside (maybe) is the amout of room it takes up. It's footprint is much larger than a baseboard heater of the same wattage. If that isn't a concern (big room) then you have a good situation for it, so price is the only downside. I've not yet run across one, but it sounds like a viable alternative for you. I'd opt for the baseboard style, but concerns with the safty of little people isn't a problem for me anymore. My *little people* are all bigger than me!
Al


--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire
Smileys



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
SteveHVAC
Member
 

Reged: 10/19/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: Rep] new
      #287213 - 10/19/06 08:35 AM

I just saw this avertised on TV recently and I was disgusted at the lies. I'm a Heating Ventilation and Air Conditioning (HVAC) Engineer.

I see others have already explained much of why this heater isn't worth anywhere near what they are asking for it.

Basically it is a light bulb in an insulated box with a fan. It is electric resistance heat ... period .... it isn't even a radiant heater.

Their energy savings claims are just plain ludicrous. The entire TV ad was so full of misinformation it made me, just now, search out a place online to warn people to stay away from this stupid "thing".

They talk about "burning" the air, completely even heat throughout a room, etc. It defies physics, let alone common sense. Almost everything they said has one shred of truth to it so they have plausible deniability but the bottom line is that this thing is, as I said before, an electric heater inside a box, with a fan.

They repeat one of my favorite pet peeve myths, that heating air removes moisture from the air ... it doesn't.


Quote:

What are your opinions about this heater?

http://www.biotechresearch.com/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=34_36&products_id=72&osCsid=3e66229f2faa035c7e2a879294b15ae0

I am mostly concerned with the cost of electric for the heat output generated. $1/day (their estimate) would probably save some money, and I would only use it when in the room. If this unit was used to heat a room at the bottom of a stairway, would the heat go up the stairway?

OK, now I'm going to the web for more fodder...




Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: SteveHVAC] new
      #287215 - 10/19/06 09:02 AM

Quote:

I just saw this avertised on TV recently and I was disgusted at the lies. I'm a Heating Ventilation and Air Conditioning (HVAC) Engineer.

I see others have already explained much of why this heater isn't worth anywhere near what they are asking for it.

Basically it is a light bulb in an insulated box with a fan. It is electric resistance heat ... period .... it isn't even a radiant heater.

Their energy savings claims are just plain ludicrous. The entire TV ad was so full of misinformation it made me, just now, search out a place online to warn people to stay away from this stupid "thing".

They talk about "burning" the air, completely even heat throughout a room, etc. It defies physics, let alone common sense. Almost everything they said has one shred of truth to it so they have plausible deniability but the bottom line is that this thing is, as I said before, an electric heater inside a box, with a fan.

They repeat one of my favorite pet peeve myths, that heating air removes moisture from the air ... it doesn't.




Thank you, thank you, thank you! Hi Steve, and welcome to our forums!! I hope you enjoy the place and decide to stop by frequently. Especially at this time of the year, we get a lot of questions that would be right up your alley, along with many other things that I believe would be of interest to you. It's always good to have extra input from people *in the buisness*, but don't be surprised if the friendships gained here overshadow even that. It's a great group of people, and I hope you stick around and get to know us. Good point about *removing* moisture from the air. Changes RH, yes, removes moisture? - not so much!
Al

--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire
Smileys



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Ted
The Other Old Geezer
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 2994
Loc: SE USA
Re: Heater [Re: SteveHVAC] new
      #287263 - 10/19/06 06:23 PM

Hi Steve.

Welcome to the HWW Forums.

--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."--H.L.Mencken
I suspect so, H.L.heh heh

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
electricheetah
Member
 

Reged: 10/20/06
Posts: 2
Re: Heater [Re: Ted] new
      #287310 - 10/20/06 12:00 PM

Off topic first post. Sorry. I have a OLD furnace in my home that only heats the front half of the home. The back half has a old wood/coal stove that needs replaced. For that matter the furnace should be too. The home is about 2,000 sq ft. I want a reliable "Cheap" heat source that is not throwing off toxic emmisions (I have birds and they have unique respretory systems). It gets pretty cold here in PA so I need a GOOD heat source. Should I just get another wood/coal stove, another furnace, both, or is there something that you would recomend?

Thanks,

Keith

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: electricheetah] new
      #287313 - 10/20/06 12:44 PM

Quote:

Off topic first post. Sorry. I have a OLD furnace in my home that only heats the front half of the home. The back half has a old wood/coal stove that needs replaced. For that matter the furnace should be too. The home is about 2,000 sq ft. I want a reliable "Cheap" heat source that is not throwing off toxic emmisions (I have birds and they have unique respretory systems). It gets pretty cold here in PA so I need a GOOD heat source. Should I just get another wood/coal stove, another furnace, both, or is there something that you would recomend?

Thanks,

Keith




Hi, Keith,

First off, welcome to the Forums!!! Always nice to pick up a new member.

I'd say the real answer depends on your situation. Most people would benefit most from getting one of the newer high-efficency gas/propane heaters. The work so well that the only "emmissions" are a small amount of water that exits through a drain and some ordinary CO2.

On the other hand, if you have a good supply of wood or coal, an air-tight Franklin/Oregon class heater would be the cheapest. Be sure to get one that draws it's combustion air from outside rather than using the warm air in the house that you've already paid to heat. Again, the newer model of those type stoves have few emissions because they employ a catalytic converter which not only gets rid of most of the noxious stuff but also increases the overall efficency. There's a wide range of models on the market. Many also contain a small fan for even better heat distribution and use only a small amount of power.

Also, depending on your local power rates, a heatpump is also a good choice. They will provide you with heat in the winter and cooling in the summer - all from the one unit. One suggestion on them is to be sure and use a gas (or propane-fired) unit for what they call "emergency heat" as opposed to the common electric strip-heaters normally installed with it. Those electric heaters are absoultely THE most expensive way on the market of getting heat.

So, check into your wood/coal avalibity and prices and consider the other alternatives I just mentioned. Let us know what you decide.


--------------------
You can see more from a mountain and from the prespective of years - but only if you keep your eyes open.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: SteveHVAC] new
      #287314 - 10/20/06 01:04 PM

Quote:

I just saw this avertised on TV recently and I was disgusted at the lies. I'm a Heating Ventilation and Air Conditioning (HVAC) Engineer.

I see others have already explained much of why this heater isn't worth anywhere near what they are asking for it.

Basically it is a light bulb in an insulated box with a fan. It is electric resistance heat ... period .... it isn't even a radiant heater.

Their energy savings claims are just plain ludicrous. The entire TV ad was so full of misinformation it made me, just now, search out a place online to warn people to stay away from this stupid "thing".

They talk about "burning" the air, completely even heat throughout a room, etc. It defies physics, let alone common sense. Almost everything they said has one shred of truth to it so they have plausible deniability but the bottom line is that this thing is, as I said before, an electric heater inside a box, with a fan.

They repeat one of my favorite pet peeve myths, that heating air removes moisture from the air ... it doesn't.




Hi, Steve,

I'm behind the power curve as usual but just want to add my own "Welcome to the Forums" to the ones you've already gotten. We've got a great bunch of folks here and we'd all be very happy to count you as regular member.

Also, we've got several folks here, including myself, who have done varing amounts of work with HVAC units. But you are our first true engineer in the field.

For my part, I've worked with heat pumps, air drier systems (both heat-recharged dessicant types and refigeration units) and was once responsibile for a computer-driven environmental system for a large installation that included a drug manufactoring facility, chemical warehouse and regular office space for about 100 people. It used both piston-driven and scroll-type staged compressors, two large chillers with evap/cooling towers and a multistage gas-fired boiler for heat. The main and individual air distrubution ducts all contained motor-driven louvers and it was possible to maintain temperature and humidity levels within 2% of the desired settings year-round. A very nice system.

As I said, I'm no engineer but I do know how to read psychometric charts (Mollier diagrams) and understand airflow and heat transfer principles involved in the various types of systems.

--------------------
You can see more from a mountain and from the prespective of years - but only if you keep your eyes open.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: electricheetah] new
      #287324 - 10/20/06 02:43 PM

Quote:

Off topic first post. Sorry. I have a OLD furnace in my home that only heats the front half of the home. The back half has a old wood/coal stove that needs replaced. For that matter the furnace should be too. The home is about 2,000 sq ft. I want a reliable "Cheap" heat source that is not throwing off toxic emmisions (I have birds and they have unique respretory systems). It gets pretty cold here in PA so I need a GOOD heat source. Should I just get another wood/coal stove, another furnace, both, or is there something that you would recomend?

Thanks,

Keith



In addition to what Old Dad said, I would recomend having a heat load calculation done first in order to size the unit (whatever you get) properly. A little more info about that, presented with a touch of humor. If you happen to be a math-o-phobic, look at the botom of that page for help with that.
Al

--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire
Smileys



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Ted
The Other Old Geezer
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 2994
Loc: SE USA
Re: Heater [Re: electricheetah] new
      #287343 - 10/20/06 07:52 PM

Hi Keith.
Welcome to the HWW Forums.
Glad you joined us.

Quote:

Off topic first post.


Perfectly OK, Here, Keith.
We do that all the time.

Well, I'm no heating system expert and my living quarters are a bit unique.
I live in an apartment in a century + old house.
My primary heat is a free standing radiant/convection type natural gas heater; electronic ignition, thermostat controlled, Martin Industries, and - if I remember correctly - about 40,000 BTU, which is a bit more capacity than I actually need. I figured it's better to have the extra capacity and not need it.

Quote:

It gets pretty cold here in PA so I need a GOOD heat source.


I'm hip!!
My Dad was born and raised in PA.

Quote:

. . . . is there something that you would recomend?


Well, no. Not me. I'm not qualified to offer advise in that area. There are others here who are far better sources of that information. You've already met a couple of them.
My only recommendation is to listen to them.


--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."--H.L.Mencken
I suspect so, H.L.heh heh

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
electricheetah
Member
 

Reged: 10/20/06
Posts: 2
Re: Heater [Re: Ted] new
      #287348 - 10/20/06 09:03 PM

Wow. I did not expect answers that quickly. Thanks!!

I appreciate all of the info that everyone has given already! I forgot to mention one thing though. We have blackouts in the winter that can occasionally last for a couple of days. I'm originally from CA. My first winter here and I'm a little nervous.

From what I have read I think that a coal/wood stove is the best option in case power goes out. I don't want to fork over more cash for a generator in case of a blizzard. I'm VERY cheap.

Thanks everyone. Your replies mean a lot and I'm going to show this info to my wife when I get home tonight.

From,

Keith

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
bcrab
Member
 

Reged: 11/09/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: electricheetah] new
      #288736 - 11/09/06 10:06 AM

I have a 1200 sq' shop, all electric no gas. What would be the best way to go about heating it? Pellet stove or a G73 Dayton electric heater or something else. What about oil filled radiator like a Honeywell? Only need to heat it up during the day time to work in, nights I dont need to keep it warm. Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: bcrab] new
      #288745 - 11/09/06 03:31 PM

Quote:

I have a 1200 sq' shop, all electric no gas. What would be the best way to go about heating it? Pellet stove or a G73 Dayton electric heater or something else. What about oil filled radiator like a Honeywell? Only need to heat it up during the day time to work in, nights I dont need to keep it warm. Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.





Hi, Bcrab,

Welcome to the Forums!

You've actually got several good choices - including the ones you've already listed.

Another is a wood heater, if you happen to have a good supply of wood close by. Yet another is a kerosene-fuelled shop heater if you have good ventilation. That's those jet-engine looking jobs with a powerful fan. They will heat up the space VERY fast. Also, you can use one for the quick first heating phase and then close things up a bit if you switch on another type - like an electric or other heater.

Another good pick is a butane/propane fuelled heater. Several models use the same refillable bottles/tanks used in gas grills. Even the ones that don't (wall mounted models) can be easily hooked up to a tank.

Personally, I happen to have plenty of wood here at home, so that would be my first choice. Otherwise, I'd pick the kerosene heater and butane heater combination for both speedy (little time lost on really cold mornings) and even heat AND because that would save a lot of money over the other choices in the long run.

--------------------
You can see more from a mountain and from the prespective of years - but only if you keep your eyes open.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
j_mech
Member
 

Reged: 11/12/06
Posts: 1
Loc: CT
Re: Heater [Re: Old Dad] new
      #288854 - 11/12/06 01:58 PM

Just adding a late note (ok, sorry - turned out to be more of a book) to the thread here... saw a whole page advertised in todays Sun. paper with the rediculuous claims that drove me to search the internet hoping to find some sense. Looks like you'all have already captured more of the truth of how well this heater may work (poorly)... but had to join the forum to comment on how the advertising bucks $$$ matter more than honest advertising.... from the Paul Harvey show to even the Google search engines makes it difficult to find honest opinions since the positions of search results are paid for .... it's all sellers and the manufacture's with their bs claims. I looked at the first three pages when searching "edenpure scam sucks disappointed"... and didn't get any objective opinions or blog sites. Of course the manufactures advertisement plays on the fears of safety and disaster (popular this days) besides other misinformation. Any device using fire, electicity, or noxious emissions should always be intalled properly and have regular maintenance by knowledgeable technicians. Also, the owner has the responsibility to read a device's cautions/warning and fully be aware of proper operation/contitions.
With the high cost of heating today, efficient design, insulation play the biggest parts of home comfort costs... for adding heat I like to keep options open, currently have effecient coal stove, wood burning fireplace insert, forced air oil heat with a large propane tank (for cooking) in reserves. The coal and wood stoves take a little work (exercise), but worth it to me for the ambiance of the glowing fire. Electric sourced resistive heat is always the most expensive. Thanks for the space - Great site!

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Ted
The Other Old Geezer
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 2994
Loc: SE USA
Re: Heater [Re: j_mech] new
      #288860 - 11/12/06 02:32 PM

Hi J_mech.

Welcome to the HWW Forums.
Glad you joined us.


Quote:

. . . . turned out to be more of a book . . . .



heh heh heh
You're in the right place.
You'll see what I mean after you read through a few of our posts.
And . . . . we're prone to going off-topic pretty often. It's more like a face-to-face conversation here.

--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."--H.L.Mencken
I suspect so, H.L.heh heh

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
LowBid
Member
 

Reged: 11/15/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: Junkman462] new
      #289175 - 11/15/06 11:59 AM

Thanks, Forum members, esp. Clockman and Ted, for the education and your insights. Great place to come for tech help and information.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
jessrw
Member
 

Reged: 11/17/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: Rep] new
      #289313 - 11/17/06 11:39 AM

I too was looking into the EdenPure.
I have a 2 bedroom home, approx. 1000 sq ft.
We have a wall gas furnace which is very loud and does not heat the kitchen and back room very well.
I was also looking at www.eheat.com as a means of heating each room.
Any comments or advice on what type of heater would be best?

Jessica


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Ted
The Other Old Geezer
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 2994
Loc: SE USA
Re: Heater [Re: jessrw] new
      #289336 - 11/17/06 06:11 PM

Hi Jessica.

Welcome to the HWW Forums.

There isn't much tech info to be gleaned from that site, but that appears to be a 400 watt radiant panel. That's roughly the heating capacity of four 100 watt light bulbs - with a 90$ price tag.
It's no bargain and, very likely, you'd be disappointed with the results.
It would probably make a good foot warmer under a desk in a cold corner.
I have an old fashioned heating pad on the floor under this desk.
For comparison, the average hair blow drier is 1200 to 1500 watts.

I just looked at my counter top bread slice toaster - it's 900 watts.

There are links to several heating calculators in this thread. They will help you determine how much heating capacity you need.
So far as the best type of heater - it depends on your particular situation and I can't offer any advise on that through an internet forum.
Ask around - friends, coworkers, neighbors and see what they use and what they like.
Or - consult a local professional heating/air conditioning specialist.
Here's a thought - Most local electric power and natural gas suppliers have people trained to audit and assess your particular needs and they can give you a well informed, professional recommendation.
Often, it's a free service. It's worth a phone call.
--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."--H.L.Mencken
I suspect so, H.L.heh heh

Edited by Ted (11/17/06 06:46 PM)

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
JMAN
Member
 

Reged: 11/20/06
Posts: 2
Loc: River Forest, IL
Re: Heater [Re: Ted] new
      #289513 - 11/20/06 01:01 PM

Another newbie to your community - the Eden Pure topic got me.

We have several electric baseboard type heaters on our sun porch and my wife saw this add and wanted me to check it out before she ordered one.

THANKS for the valuable info - I hope to come back to the community often and hopefully have some input as valuable as what I received today !!!!!


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Ted
The Other Old Geezer
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 2994
Loc: SE USA
Re: Heater [Re: JMAN] new
      #289529 - 11/20/06 06:36 PM

Hi Jman.
Welcome to the HWW Forums.

Quote:

THANKS for the valuable info . . . .


Glad we could help.

Quote:

. . . . hope to come back to the community often . . . .


Please do.
We'll be glad to 'see' ya.

--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."--H.L.Mencken
I suspect so, H.L.heh heh

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Joxer
Member
 

Reged: 11/29/06
Posts: 2
Loc: Cheyenne, WY
Re: Heater [Re: JMAN] new
      #290029 - 11/29/06 10:19 AM

This is a wonderful forum, I am glad to have found it.
I have a large shop that I am framing in a bathroom and rec room, in the back area of the shop. It will have lots of insulation and the main room is about 1500 sq ft, and the bath room is about 150 sq ft. I have no natural gas available or propane, just electric. I could have a propane tank installed and go that way if someone can give me good info on how to use it to heat and of course the big question is money$$$ for what type of heater (duct work and venting) to be installed.
Electric is inviting because I can heat just the rooms I am in and I do not have to install anything but the heater in each location. I do not have to worry about duct work, and insulating it. I have been looking at the Comfort Cove radiant cove heaters, that my local rural electric company sells and wonder if any of you have info or opinions on this brand and type of heating. I am planning on having a tiled floor and will have an older wood stove to use as needed too. It is not the most efficient wood stove but should be more than adequate to heat the area. I just do not want to rely on it for everything. The bathroom will be self contained and will need to be heated in the winter. I live in Wyoming and the winters can get cold, the high today will be about 10 degrees. Any and all help is greatly appreciated, I just hope I put this question in the right place to be seen by as many of you as possible.

Thanks,
Joxer

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
chupa
Member
 

Reged: 11/29/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: Joxer] new
      #290042 - 11/29/06 01:42 PM

Hi All-

Just thought I would post my 2 cents. My Dad bought one of these a few weeks ago - didnt work for him. he has a 60 yo split level - and was running it on a slab. Apparently it states it doesnt work well if sitting on a slab. Anyway - he gave it to me - I have a 250+ yo farm house in PA. It hasnt gotten extremely cold here yet - but the other night it was below 30 and it kept 1000 sq ft of my dowstairs at 65 degrees. I usualy have my woodstove running 24x7 to keep downstairs at 60. Moved it upstairs at night and it kept that 800+ sq ft at 66 degrees all night. Everyone who has been over to visit lately has asked why the house is so warm. I only let the baseboard heat come on in middle of the night when the wood stove dies down.

So I was searching the internet to see if other people who used this heater for a period of time found the electric bill to be as low as advertised - because the heating portion seems to be good. will let you know after it gets cold.



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Joxer
Member
 

Reged: 11/29/06
Posts: 2
Loc: Cheyenne, WY
Re: Heater [Re: Rep] new
      #290093 - 11/30/06 10:45 AM

I have a large shop that I am framing in a bathroom and rec room, in the back area of the shop. It will have lots of insulation and the main room is about 1500 sq ft, and the bath room is about 150 sq ft. I have no natural gas available or propane, just electric. I could have a propane tank installed and go that way if someone can give me good info on how to use it to heat and of course the big question is money$$$ for what type of heater (duct work and venting) to be installed.
Electric is inviting because I can heat just the rooms I am in and I do not have to install anything but the heater in each location. I do not have to worry about duct work, and insulating it. I have been looking at the Comfort Cove radiant cove heaters, that my local rural electric company sells and wonder if any of you have info or opinions on this brand and type of heating. I am planning on having a tiled floor and will have an older wood stove to use as needed too. It is not the most efficient wood stove but should be more than adequate to heat the area. I just do not want to rely on it for everything. The bathroom will be self contained and will need to be heated in the winter. I live in Wyoming and the winters can get cold, the high today will be about 10 degrees. Any and all help is greatly appreciated, I just hope I put this question in the right place to be seen by as many of you as possible.

I have also found a new radiant heating company with heating panels. This also looks interesting. I would love to hear what anyone else thinks of my above questions and of Enerjoy radiant heating panels. They have a snazy name called Enerjoy randiant people heaters. At there website; www.enerjoy.com, they go into great detail and show many studies and reports about the wonders of there products. I would love to see what you educated people can tell me about this type of product as well.

Thanks again,
Joxer

Thanks,
Joxer

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
dabac
contrary consumer
 

Reged: 08/04/03
Posts: 1748
Loc: Stockholm, Sweden, Northern Europe
Re: Heater [Re: Joxer] new
      #290108 - 11/30/06 12:52 PM

Had a quick look at the site, slow loading and real data not immediately available. But those are heating panels meant to be placed on the ceiling that they're selling ?

If that is the case - steer well clear of this system! Ceiling heating was popular around here for a few years 20-30 years ago, but has now mercifully enough died out.

Ignore the FAQ, when it isn't outright wrong, its data is so twisted as to be next to useless. If we all pitched in we could undoubtedly have some sardonic laughs debunking just about every answer provided there.

Main disadvantage - heat rises. Sticking the heating element on the ceiling and aiming it downwards is a study in ignorance of basic physical phenomena. Spitting into a headwind comes to mind.



It works, sort of, for bar heaters with reflectors, but with the drawback that if you're sitting at a table your legs will not feel any of the warmth projected at you, since it's stopped by the table. The FAQ is sort of right when it says that heat will reradiate but it conveniently refrains from mentioning the losses. Basically if you wish reradiated heat to reach comfortable levels then the directly radiated heat would have to be pretty much scorching.

For a big panel like that radiation isn't at all that pronounced, so it will do considerably worse.

Another disadvantage - you'll be warmer at the head and colder around your feet - which incidentially is fairly close to the immediate opposite of the temperature distribution most of us would consider to be ideal.

The only reason that I can think of for these systems to still exist is ease of installation. Ceilings are the least used surface in our homes, so as long as you leave room enough for the occasional lamp it's all yours, and you don't need to concern yourself with risk of mechanical damage to the heating elements either.

--------------------
Unpleasant truth of the day - You're unique, but that doesn't make you special.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
tflan
Member
 

Reged: 12/02/06
Posts: 2
Re: Heater [Re: Ted] new
      #290281 - 12/02/06 02:03 PM

Hi; This is my first post here. Great pages! Re: the EdenPure. I just rec'd a blurb in the mail about it. Some questions here ask about "copper heat exchanger" and wattage use. The advert states that there is "specially treated copper" which makes the unit more efficient, which is IMO, so much B.S. I looked for these on ebay and found a dealer who mentions that the unit uses "1.263 kw/h". You can do the math. It seems to me the adage "if it sounds too good to be true, it isn't true", applies to these $400 space heaters.

tflan

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Ted
The Other Old Geezer
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 2994
Loc: SE USA
Re: Heater [Re: tflan] new
      #290286 - 12/02/06 05:53 PM

Hi Tflan.
Welcome to the HWW Forums.

Quote:

. . . . "if it sounds too good to be true, it isn't true", applies to these $400 space heaters.


You are correct.
Nearly all these plug-in heaters are 1500 watts, and like Clockman said, 1500 watts is 1500 watts no matter how you slice it.

Quote:

The advert states that there is "specially treated copper" which makes the unit more efficient, which is IMO, so much B.S.


That's my opinion, too.
They could tie a pink ribbon and bow, add a flashing light and it would Still be a 1500 watt heater.

I've recently seen plastic cased 1500 watt plug-in heaters at WalMart for $9.96 but I'd stick with the $20 metal cased variety.

--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."--H.L.Mencken
I suspect so, H.L.heh heh

Edited by Ted (12/02/06 06:12 PM)

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
tflan
Member
 

Reged: 12/02/06
Posts: 2
Re: Heater [Re: Ted] new
      #290445 - 12/05/06 02:40 PM

Well, after a lot of looking, reading, and shopping for a heater I decided to buy a DeLonghi. Not for me though, for my son who's a relatively new father. My grandson is 8 months old and has just been moved to his own room. Apartment doesn't have central heating so the room, which measures roughly 10' x 12' seemed to be a good candidate for an oil heater. So I went shopping. Amazon has some pretty good deals on these. However, like Baruka Salt in "Willy Wonka" I wanted it NOW! I found a DeLonghi clone at Target - a "Honeywell" brand which was clearly a renamed Delonghi.It had wheels, a digital thermostat, 3 heat settings, and a timer. $59.95. So I bought it. Took it out of the box. It was ugly :-( Black, unshielded heat elements, ugh So I took it back. At Lowes there was a real Delonghi "Dragon" on sale for $59.95, marked down $10.00. The same heater at OSH was $89.95! I tried it out in my house, which is an open design . . . not too good for here but, it does work very well in my grandson's small room. The timer's a little hokey but other than that, it's a good choice for a small room ;-)

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
ss06
Member
 

Reged: 12/05/06
Posts: 4
Re: Heater [Re: tflan] new
      #290494 - 12/05/06 07:34 PM

Hi, this is my first post as well. I read the ad in Sundays paper, and looked it up thru google. I went to several websites to read about it, and was convinced it was what I needed until I clicked on this website that I found thru google. Our problem is that we have a 2 story home, a real 2 story home, there are 20 stairs to get to the lower level. The gas furnace is on the bottom floor, and it works well, its set for the degree we want and it automatically turns on and off. Ok, so now, the downstairs is very cold when it gets really cold outside. The reason being, that the heat rises up to the upper level, and it never really reaches downstairs. I have a den, 3 bedrooms, and a computer/office downstairs. Needless to say the bedrooms get very cold. I have a radiating heater, I guess its a oil heater, has the numbers in front and 2 tabs. So you can use just one tab or the 2. The problem is that it only heats up the den area and if I have other lights on, the tv, upstairs lights are being used, etc, then it throws the circuit. So, after reading all these posts, I am so confused now. I thought from reading the ad, that this heater threw out the heat until the whole room was warm. I am so glad I came upon this site. I searched for a ceramic heater with fan on google and came up with this: http://www.heatershop.com/cth2_ceramic_space_heater.html----of course, thats just one of the hundreds, I'm sure. What do you all suggest?

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
ss06
Member
 

Reged: 12/05/06
Posts: 4
Re: Heater [Re: ss06] new
      #290495 - 12/05/06 07:59 PM

I have since been looking at several heaters online. I guess if I go to Sears, or any home improvement center, I can find one but I would like to know, what to choose. Our electric bill in the winter is really really high! We have an all gas home, washer, dryer, stove, furnace. I came upon this one Delonghi Advanced Oil Filled Radiator Heater 9707SRB which resembles the one I have, but mine is a lot older and doesn't have the features. Wouldn't a heater with a fan, be a good idea? Any and all feedback welcomed

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Ted
The Other Old Geezer
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 2994
Loc: SE USA
Re: Heater [Re: ss06] new
      #290509 - 12/05/06 11:10 PM

Hi ss06.
Welcome to the HWW Forums.

Let's try this.

OK.
That's another 1500 watt, 117 VAC plug-it-in-the wall heater. It will heat the same as the $20 variety.
All models shown on that web site are 1500 watt heaters - except the 220/240 VAC models which are more efficient and less costly to operate per BTU - if you have a 220 VAC receptacle available.

None of these plug-in heaters are going to heat your whole downstairs.
These plug-in heaters are good for keeping your toes warm under a desk in a cold corner.

It doesn't matter how it's packaged, 1500 watts is 1500 watts and 1500 watts is equal to 5120 BTU - same as a dollar store hair blow drier.

Quote:

Our electric bill in the winter is really really high!


Any of these plug-in heaters are going are going to increase your electric bill.

Quote:

The gas furnace is on the bottom floor . . . .


What type system do you have?
Central unit with ducts and forced air circulation - or something else?

Quote:

I have a radiating heater, I guess its a oil heater, has the numbers in front and 2 tabs.


I'll bet it's an Oil Filled and rated at 1500 watts. The oil is sealed inside the heater. It doesn't contribute to the actual heating capacity. It maintains a more constant, even heating as the thermostat cycles the actual heating elements on and off.

Quote:

. . . . then it throws the circuit.


Yep.
That's why these plug-in heaters are limited to 1500 watts. That's about all you can draw from the 'average' wall receptacle. These little heaters draw about 13 Amps.



--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."--H.L.Mencken
I suspect so, H.L.heh heh

Edited by Ted (12/05/06 11:32 PM)

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
ss06
Member
 

Reged: 12/05/06
Posts: 4
Re: Heater [Re: Ted] new
      #290515 - 12/06/06 12:04 AM

Hi, thank you for your reply. Yes, our gas furnace is a Central unit with ducts and forced air circulation. And the plug in heater is oil filled. It gets very hot to the touch and its heavy. It's lasted for a long time, I was hoping there would be a newer type of plug in heater, That would heat bigger spaces, etc. We would have installed a fireplace downstairs if we could but we can't because the duct for the fireplace, would go straight thru the top floor, and if we would try and install a franklin stove or something similar, we can't either, because there is a porch right outside the den, and it can't flow upwards. We can't install anything that needs to be vented on the downstairs floor because of the awkward layout. My daughter had a small tiny heater that would blow hot air out in her bedroom (long time ago) and it would throw off the circuit. It was a small thing. I went to look at the one you listed and it looks good, I'll show it to hubby. I'm doing the research, I'm the scout Forgot to mention, our bedroom is on the top level, so we're nice and warm upstairs. Thanks for your reply, if you find anything else, I would appreciate your advice.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: ss06] new
      #290524 - 12/06/06 01:49 AM

Quote:

Hi, thank you for your reply. Yes, our gas furnace is a Central unit with ducts and forced air circulation. And the plug in heater is oil filled. It gets very hot to the touch and its heavy. It's lasted for a long time, I was hoping there would be a newer type of plug in heater, That would heat bigger spaces, etc. We would have installed a fireplace downstairs if we could but we can't because the duct for the fireplace, would go straight thru the top floor, and if we would try and install a franklin stove or something similar, we can't either, because there is a porch right outside the den, and it can't flow upwards. We can't install anything that needs to be vented on the downstairs floor because of the awkward layout. My daughter had a small tiny heater that would blow hot air out in her bedroom (long time ago) and it would throw off the circuit. It was a small thing. I went to look at the one you listed and it looks good, I'll show it to hubby. I'm doing the research, I'm the scout Forgot to mention, our bedroom is on the top level, so we're nice and warm upstairs. Thanks for your reply, if you find anything else, I would appreciate your advice.




Hi, SS,

The first part of this isn't addressed directly at you but is just some general statements to clear up some facts, OK? But I do have something for you in just a moment.

The majority of the heaters discussed in this thread are nothing more than simple electrical-resistance heat-generating devices. Regardless of how they are packaged/housed, the operating principle is precisely the same as an electric oven, hair blow-dryer or tabletop bread toaster.

And although everyone may not be aware of it, heating by way of electrical resistance is absolutely the MOST expensive method known to humankind! Anything - and I mean anything else is cheaper. The only genuine attraction for such units is their simplicity of installation and use - buy them & plug 'em in. But the owners of these devices will pay dearly for that convenience every time the power bill arrives.

Now, specifically for you, SS, and a couple of other folks as well. A good alternative for your needs is a vented/ventless gas heater. There are hundreds of different makes & models to choose from and they're practically maintenance free. (Perhaps once every year or two, they may need the dust blown out of the tiny pilot-light jet - and that's it.) I picked this little article for you to check for more information on them. One reason for selecting it is that it mentions a very specific item that's an absolute MUST (in my opinion) for any gas heater - an oxygen-depletion sensor. And even though the article specifically addresses garages, the things are useful anywhere.

On a personal note, I have three of them in my own home. I live in the foothills of the North Georgia mountains. The roads are narrow and heavily lined with tall trees. Power failures of several hours (and even days, during ice and snowstorms) are fairly common. Without power, my central heat is completely useless. And those three little units keep us warm and cozy regardless. And now that I'm thinking about it, they even light up the floor at night, too.

--------------------
Light travels faster than sound; that's why people seem brighter - until you hear them.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
ss06
Member
 

Reged: 12/05/06
Posts: 4
Re: Heater [Re: Old Dad] new
      #290580 - 12/06/06 01:09 PM

Quote:

Hi, SS,

Now, specifically for you, SS, and a couple of other folks as well. A good alternative for your needs is a vented/ventless gas heater. There are hundreds of different makes & models to choose from and they're practically maintenance free. (Perhaps once every year or two, they may need the dust blown out of the tiny pilot-light jet - and that's it.) I picked this little article for you to check for more information on them. One reason for selecting it is that it mentions a very specific item that's an absolute MUST (in my opinion) for any gas heater - an oxygen-depletion sensor. And even though the article specifically addresses garages, the things are useful anywhere.

On a personal note, I have three of them in my own home. I live in the foothills of the North Georgia mountains. The roads are narrow and heavily lined with tall trees. Power failures of several hours (and even days, during ice and snowstorms) are fairly common. Without power, my central heat is completely useless. And those three little units keep us warm and cozy regardless. And now that I'm thinking about it, they even light up the floor at night, too.



Hello Old Dad I think you might have solved our problem! I don't know why we had not considered these heaters. Well, I do know one reason, the gas line would have to be brought from the computer room which use to be the utility room. We built a utility room next to it, so the utility room became the computer room and we have the room next it for the washing machine and dryer. I guess the gas man that does our furnace, etc every year, might be able to come up with a solution. I'm also thinking that a heater that needs to be vented could possibly be installed on the wall near the door leading to the outside porch. I don't think the vent would be that unsightly from the outside. My gas dryer has a vent, and it leads to the outside, and is located on the ground level. So, if we got a vented gas heater, that line could be done the same way as the gas dryer, don't you think? I think the most expensive part of this project would be the gas man, bringing the line thru the other room. Now that you say you have three, why couldn't I also put one in the bedroom (which is now a craft, everything room)? The gas outlet which is covered up right now (since its my computer room) is the source or the furnace which is located in the computer room as well. If this is not convenient or unsightly, then the ventless gas heater is the way to go. Why hadn't we considered this before? I guess we thought it was dangerous? I don't know. I know we had considered a fireplace, but due to the layout of the house, it was not possible. I'm so happy I found this forum. Thank you for your reply and your patience. By the way, what type of gas heater do you have, is it a gas heater type (box type) or a log burning heater?

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: ss06] new
      #290591 - 12/06/06 04:15 PM

Quote:

Hello Old Dad I think you might have solved our problem! I don't know why we had not considered these heaters. Well, I do know one reason, the gas line would have to be brought from the computer room which use to be the utility room. We built a utility room next to it, so the utility room became the computer room and we have the room next it for the washing machine and dryer. I guess the gas man that does our furnace, etc every year, might be able to come up with a solution. I'm also thinking that a heater that needs to be vented could possibly be installed on the wall near the door leading to the outside porch. I don't think the vent would be that unsightly from the outside. My gas dryer has a vent, and it leads to the outside, and is located on the ground level. So, if we got a vented gas heater, that line could be done the same way as the gas dryer, don't you think? I think the most expensive part of this project would be the gas man, bringing the line thru the other room. Now that you say you have three, why couldn't I also put one in the bedroom (which is now a craft, everything room)? The gas outlet which is covered up right now (since its my computer room) is the source or the furnace which is located in the computer room as well. If this is not convenient or unsightly, then the ventless gas heater is the way to go. Why hadn't we considered this before? I guess we thought it was dangerous? I don't know. I know we had considered a fireplace, but due to the layout of the house, it was not possible. I'm so happy I found this forum. Thank you for your reply and your patience. By the way, what type of gas heater do you have, is it a gas heater type (box type) or a log burning heater?




Hi, SS,

Good - I'm glad I may have helped.

The ones pictured and listed here are very similar to the ones I have. We've got one of each shown - the largest one takes care of the livingroom/dining room/kitchen, the middle one is in a rather large room (combination bedroom & kitchen) that was intended for my Father until he passed away, and I had the smallest installed in just one bathroom - again, intended just for during power failures.

Also, since they are intended primarily for use during power outages, I didn't buy the optional electric blowers - they wouldn't be much use then, would they? Consequently, I don't know how effective the blowers are for regular use but I suspect they might be good to have for your purpose. They would help a little in spreading the heat around more quickly and evenly.

And I must confess that being sort of a frugal type (which is my basic nature) that I also use them at times when my wife and I are home alone. No need to heat this whole *BIG* house for just the two of us. So that saves gas and takes no power for the central blower.

And seriously - you'd be pretty amazed at just how little gas these units take while keeping you nice and toasty. Also, while using them in the winter, I enjoy walking out and looking at my power meter - the thing is hardly moving! {Heh-heh-heh!}

--------------------
Light travels faster than sound; that's why people seem brighter - until you hear them.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Ted
The Other Old Geezer
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 2994
Loc: SE USA
Re: Heater [Re: ss06] new
      #290621 - 12/06/06 08:18 PM

Hi ss06.

Quote:

I went to look at the one you listed and it looks good . . .


Ah - that was your link. I just tidied it up a bit.

Quote:

Yes, our gas furnace is a Central unit with ducts and forced air circulation.


Hmmmm . . . .
I'm wondering if you need to adjust the dampers in the ducts to force more of the heat to the downstairs.
Read through this thread - especially the last couple of posts.

Otherwise, the type gas heaters Old Dad mentioned are exactly the type I installed in my apartment to replace the existing antique space heaters.
I used Martin brand, but only because I got a very good price from a friend who owns a small hardware store. I'm not making a brand name recommendation here. They were the previous years left over stock.
These heaters a really nice. I'm more than happy with 'em.

--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."--H.L.Mencken
I suspect so, H.L.heh heh

Edited by Ted (12/06/06 08:43 PM)

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
fox
Member
 

Reged: 12/07/06
Posts: 2
Re: Heater [Re: Ted] new
      #290733 - 12/07/06 09:41 PM

I just wanted to thank the folks on this website for the information about the EdenPURE quartz infrared portable heaters. You have saved my husband and I a lot of money. We got a kick out of some of the comments.

My husband and I are Rotary members and my husband said it was advertised in their newsletter. He wanted to order it but asked me to check on the internet to get customer reviews. Boy, I'm glad we did!

I'm going to send Rotary Intl a message about it. Do you know any good sources to include with this website for customer reviews/professional opinions?

Thanks again!

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: fox] new
      #290740 - 12/08/06 12:16 AM

Quote:

I just wanted to thank the folks on this website for the information about the EdenPURE quartz infrared portable heaters. You have saved my husband and I a lot of money. We got a kick out of some of the comments.

My husband and I are Rotary members and my husband said it was advertised in their newsletter. He wanted to order it but asked me to check on the internet to get customer reviews. Boy, I'm glad we did!

I'm going to send Rotary Intl a message about it. Do you know any good sources to include with this website for customer reviews/professional opinions?

Thanks again!




Hi, Fox,

Glad you decided to check with us. A little shamless plug, if I may? Please come back anytime and also tell your friends about us - we might be able to help them with something as well. We've got a nice freindly group of folks here who, if combined, represent a few hundred years of collective experience in practically everything under the sun. They cover everthing from heating, plumbing, air conditioning, telephones, power distribution (commercial and residental), a real practicing doctor (MD) and - are you ready for this? - a physicist who designs and works on atomic clocks AND a genuine rocket scientist employed by NASA! If you can name it, the chances are very good that someone here knows about it.

I don't know of the kind of site you've asked about, maybe someone else does, but I'd always suggest Consumer Reports as a good place to start. They are not connected in any way with the people who make and sell the things they test and therefore give unbiased reports.

Just coincidentally, by the way, I was also a member of the Rotary and the Chamber of Commerce before I retired. They are also nice folks - but always remember that they ARE in the business of promoting their members. So advertising and promotions are a natural part of what they do.

Hope to see you back again soon!!!

Old Dad


--------------------
Light travels faster than sound; that's why people seem brighter - until you hear them.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: fox] new
      #290761 - 12/08/06 09:38 AM

Quote:

I just wanted to thank the folks on this website for the information about the EdenPURE quartz infrared portable heaters. You have saved my husband and I a lot of money. We got a kick out of some of the comments.

My husband and I are Rotary members and my husband said it was advertised in their newsletter. He wanted to order it but asked me to check on the internet to get customer reviews. Boy, I'm glad we did!

I'm going to send Rotary Intl a message about it. Do you know any good sources to include with this website for customer reviews/professional opinions?

Thanks again!



Hi fox. Please allow me to mimic Old Dad's response with my own invitation to *drop by anytime*, and glad we could help. "We", being EVERYONE on this site. I would also like to say that for customer reviews of things *in general*, you've already found a durn good place to get them! Though the members here may not have tried every product out there, *we* do have the means to find out about just about anything you could want, and that almost always includes links to other sites, expert and non expert opinions, and likely more information than you might origionally be asking for. Some of us tend to be a bit *long winded* sometimes. Along the way, you'll find we tend to go *off track* and get into related things as well, but your questions will ALWAYS be answered as well. So rather than look for a specific site for product reviews, why not just give us a try first? Over time, you'll not only get those links, but you may just make a few friends and share in some fun with the rest of us. We're a friendly group, and always willing AND able to help. I think you'll find on the rare occasion where at LEAST one of our members doesn't have the answer to something, by threads end, MOST of us do. We tend to go a bit overboard (in a good way ) researching things we don't know about.
Drop by anytime, and often!
Al

--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire
Smileys
Don't take life so seriously. It isn't permanent!



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
fox
Member
 

Reged: 12/07/06
Posts: 2
Re: Heater [Re: GrandfatherClock] new
      #290944 - 12/10/06 11:18 AM

Thanks, Old Dad and Clockman!

I'll certainly come back.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
JSB
Member
 

Reged: 12/14/06
Posts: 3
Re: Heater [Re: dabac] new
      #291462 - 12/14/06 07:23 AM

Quote:



Had a quick google, apparently it's only oil-filled - you had a serious malfunction in that unit and that really shouldn't happen. Bring it back to the dealer and see what they say.
I run three units of similar function in my garage and haven't had any trouble. The local Scouts house is also heated solely by those, around a dozen of them. One has sprung a leak and got discarded, that's all.


How one piece of equipment reacted can be a very poor indicator of how another piece of equipment would react. Radios for the most part are basically low voltage designs, they all have a considerable amount of power conditioner circuitry in them. Try pulling the plug while the radio is playing and you are quite likely to have a couple of sceonds of noise before the radio realizes that the feed is broken. Not all machines are so forgiving.
If you had a malfunction of the same order of magnitude in an edenpure as the one you had in your Holmes it would be about as likely to start a fire. Anything connected to the mains has the potential to start a fire, if it develops a short/poor connection at the most inappropiate place.





Being an electrician and seeing this happen many times it's usually the outlet quality and or the wiring job itself.

I went into a theater that had the same model heater in one of there dressing rooms. The outlet that the unit was plugged into was melted beyond belief only because some person was confident enough they didn't need an electrician to wire outlets around the mirrors. Well not having any knowledge they didn't realize that you MUST make sure the wires that connect to the outlets are tightly secured. They just wrapped the wires around the screws and never even tightened the screws! What happens here is the more current (watts/amps) draw the larger the wire needs to be or it becomes a resistor which is how a heating element works. is this case the loose connection on the outlet was a big resistor that was starting to arc when this happens carbon starts to buildup and get even hotter! Sorry for the long explanation. I would honestly have the outlet and the wiring looked at. Also the radio was unaffected because it doesn't pull anywhere the current the heater pulls. The other possible problem which is common also is the plug on the heater is cheaply made and they stamp the wire to the brass prong that is encased in the rubber plug. sometime the same scenario as mentioned above. if the outlets OK you can cut off the bad plug and replace it with a new plug from your local hardware store, just make sure you tighten the screw terminals over the wire real good.
Hope this helps and glad youre home didn't go up in flames.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: fox] new
      #291463 - 12/14/06 07:39 AM

Quote:

Thanks, Old Dad and Clockman!

I'll certainly come back.





On behalf of both of us, you're very welcome, Fox. Hope to see you again soon.

--------------------
Light travels faster than sound; that's why people seem brighter - until you hear them.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
JSB
Member
 

Reged: 12/14/06
Posts: 3
Re: Heater [Re: bassman] new
      #291464 - 12/14/06 07:46 AM

Quote:

I have one of these and have some info.

1) The company "Portable Furnace" is in Winnipeg, Canada. They have a website www.portablefurnace.com. Also, for what it's worth mine heats my basement great (around 300 sq. ft.). It uses infrared bulbs that are 375 watts each. The way it works (so they tell me) is the air when heated is forced through a heat exchanger, like a furnace, and a fan blows it out. The big difference I like, rather than space heaters, is that my kids can play around it without knocking it over and/or burning them or my carpet. I shelled out some bucks for this so maybe I'm biased. It works for me and lives up to claims, at least so far. Thoughts?




Let's see here
4 heat lamps 15.00
4 ceramic lamp sockets 18.00
cabinet materials 15.00
thermostat module 15.00
Muffin fan 3.50
Aluminum heat exchanger 10.00
other misc. items 15.00

Total 91.50
Probably costs them 50.00 since they are being mas produced in Vietnam.

Dude! Whose getting screwed here! You can buy a portable baseboard heater and put it under a window and I bet you would get the same or better results for 39.95 and most of them are safe for kids. almost all space heaters today have tip sensors in them to help prevent fires.



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: JSB] new
      #291465 - 12/14/06 07:59 AM

Quote:

Being an electrician and seeing this happen many times it's usually the outlet quality and or the wiring job itself.

I went into a theater that had the same model heater in one of there dressing rooms. The outlet that the unit was plugged into was melted beyond belief only because some person was confident enough they didn't need an electrician to wire outlets around the mirrors. Well not having any knowledge they didn't realize that you MUST make sure the wires that connect to the outlets are tightly secured. They just wrapped the wires around the screws and never even tightened the screws! What happens here is the more current (watts/amps) draw the larger the wire needs to be or it becomes a resistor which is how a heating element works. is this case the loose connection on the outlet was a big resistor that was starting to arc when this happens carbon starts to buildup and get even hotter! Sorry for the long explanation. I would honestly have the outlet and the wiring looked at. Also the radio was unaffected because it doesn't pull anywhere the current the heater pulls. The other possible problem which is common also is the plug on the heater is cheaply made and they stamp the wire to the brass prong that is encased in the rubber plug. sometime the same scenario as mentioned above. if the outlets OK you can cut off the bad plug and replace it with a new plug from your local hardware store, just make sure you tighten the screw terminals over the wire real good.
Hope this helps and glad youre home didn't go up in flames.




Hi, JSB,

Welcome to the Forums!!!! It's always very nice to have a new member, especially a professional! Sure hope you hang around.

Though I've never been lisicend, I've worked under several and have seen exactly what you're talking about. One thing that always struck me when dealing with old work was how often the wiring was undersized. But I also must admit that some of dated back to when #14 was quite acceptable when it was installed because power usage was much smaller back then. I've also worked in homes that had a 50-amp service. Guess that will tell you the time-period I'm talking about.

Another dangerous thing that you used to see a lot of, and still do, is outlets and branch circuits that are overloaded through the use of extension cords and octopuss plugs. Even in homes today where the number of outlets in each room are much more plentiful than they used to be, often times they are blocked by furniture and the homeowner will overload the ones they can easily get to.

Incidentally, as a phone company employee working in what we called Outside Plant, I've also done *tons* of commercial/industrial wiring as well. All the way up to 3-0 cableing. One of the few times I actually had to use a pipewrench to make some of the necessary bends. {Heh-heh-heh!}

I always enjoyed it and took a great deal of pride in making good, solid connections, neat runs, properly labled breakers, etc. It's certainly one field where quality of workmanship is important. Both in terms of operation AND safety.

--------------------
Light travels faster than sound; that's why people seem brighter - until you hear them.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
JSB
Member
 

Reged: 12/14/06
Posts: 3
Re: Heater [Re: Old Dad] new
      #291466 - 12/14/06 08:13 AM

Quote:


I always enjoyed it and took a great deal of pride in making good, solid connections, neat runs, properly labeled breakers, etc. It's certainly one field where quality of workmanship is important. Both in terms of operation AND safety.




I bet when you're done wiring a panel, you stand back and look at it like you just painted the Mona Lisa. I do....

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: JSB] new
      #291467 - 12/14/06 09:01 AM

Quote:

I bet when you're done wiring a panel, you stand back and look at it like you just painted the Mona Lisa. I do....



LEO! Long time no see! Have you finished 'supper' yet?
Hi JSB. Welcome to the forums, and thanks for your input. Some very good pointers and safety tips there. Like you, and *the old one* I tend to take a step back too, to look at what has been done, hopefully admiringly, but more importantly, to make sure nothing has been forgotten. It's a good feeling when you can stand back and know what you've done is not only workable, but safe and neatly done. Then lock the panel so the inevitable electrical gremlins can't get it! It's always interesting to see the inside of a panel several people have been in. You can almost see the people through the quality of their work, and tell who did the origional install vs the add ons.
Al


--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire
Smileys
Don't take life so seriously. It isn't permanent!



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
RzrsegAdministrator
Head Zoo Keeper
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 8834
Loc: Houston, Texas
Re: Heater [Re: JSB] new
      #291468 - 12/14/06 09:30 AM

Quote:

I bet when you're done wiring a panel, you stand back and look at it like you just painted the Mona Lisa. I do....


The last time I bought a house I was walking around with the inspector when he got to the electrical panel. He took the cover off and we both just stood there and sighed. It was gorgeous. ALL the turns looked like they had been formed by by a little pipe bender. Virtually nothing was crossing over, there was no little bits of insulation or flotsam in the box. It was fantastic.


--------------------
People are more violently opposed to fur than leather because it's safer to harass rich women than motorcycle gangs.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: JSB] new
      #291469 - 12/14/06 09:33 AM

Quote:

I bet when you're done wiring a panel, you stand back and look at it like you just painted the Mona Lisa. I do....




Yup! Like you, I consider it a work of art. I like to see all the runs going straight into the box with no kinks, all the jacket stripped off inside the box, all the blacks going into the breakers at clean 90-degree angles, the whites run to the neutral buss without curls and a lot of slack AND the lables neatly printed so that *anyone* can read them and tell the difference between "living room" and "utility room." Makes you feel good, doesn't it?

--------------------
Light travels faster than sound; that's why people seem brighter - until you hear them.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: Rzrseg] new
      #291470 - 12/14/06 09:38 AM

Quote:

The last time I bought a house I was walking around with the inspector when he got to the electrical panel. He took the cover off and we both just stood there and sighed. It was gorgeous. ALL the turns looked like they had been formed by by a little pipe bender. Virtually nothing was crossing over, there was no little bits of insulation or flotsam in the box. It was fantastic.




Hi, Rzr,

And you can bet that the guy who finished it was feeling good as he was lifting up the cover to go on it. A true professional, he was!

--------------------
Light travels faster than sound; that's why people seem brighter - until you hear them.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
dabac
contrary consumer
 

Reged: 08/04/03
Posts: 1748
Loc: Stockholm, Sweden, Northern Europe
Re: Heater [Re: Old Dad] new
      #291734 - 12/18/06 05:27 AM

Quote:

..I like to see all the runs going straight into the box with no kinks, all the jacket stripped off inside the box, all the blacks going into the breakers at clean 90-degree angles, the whites run to the neutral buss without curls and a lot of slack...




While there is a certain neatness to the precisely tailored installation, I prefer there to be a certain (planned) excess of cable available somewhere. Makes it ever so much easier (and neater afterwards) if one component has to be replaced with one with a slightly differing physical design. If I'm already doing a bend for instance I am quite likely to take that as an opportunity to place a loop or two there(nicely strapped and secure of course!) to save a few inches of cable for future needs.

One of my least favourite jobs was/is dealing with the internal tv/radio distribution network in the building. Each socket has some splitter componentry in it, which consumes just about all available space in the wall mounted housing. The cables have to be trimmed so precisely that even attaching them in the first place is a delicate operation. And if for some reason the cables ends up being shortened (due to replacing a socket or so) then there is usually not much choice than to replace the whole run to the next outlet, in both directions.


--------------------
Unpleasant truth of the day - You're unique, but that doesn't make you special.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Lachmac
Member
 

Reged: 12/18/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: Junkman462] new
      #291801 - 12/18/06 10:45 PM

We just had a direct mail solicitation for Eden Pure from Biotech and had a difficult time finding listings, reviews and comparisons. Your review was thorough and persuasive. Thanks for saving us from buying features available at much lower prices. Next thing we want to find out about is the Monitor fuel oil heaters. Thanks,

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
tommy_tater
Member
 

Reged: 12/18/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: Lachmac] new
      #291811 - 12/18/06 11:44 PM

Well, I have read thru a great deal of the comments and it seems there are a great deal of complaints but not many of the people complaining have tried it yet. I also read complaints about not being able to find the BTU rating & the Watts that it uses. I looked up the add and found this out easily.

The EdenPURE 500 uses 750 Watts, draws 6.5 amps & is rated at 2300 BTU's
The EdenPURE 1000 uses 1500 Watts, draws 12.6 amps & is rated at 5000 BTU's

I'm still skeptical on this heater, I'll have to do more research.
Happy Holidays!!!

Edited by tommy_tater (12/18/06 11:48 PM)

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Ted
The Other Old Geezer
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 2994
Loc: SE USA
Re: Heater [Re: Lachmac] new
      #291812 - 12/18/06 11:46 PM

Hi Lachmac.

Welcome to the HWW Forums.

Those appear to be good heaters.
Here is their website.

The only drawbacks are having to handle the fuel manually and they require normal household 117 VAC electric supply to operate the control and ignition systems. If the power is out, ya won't have any heat. Even if you add the accessory power inverter, when the batteries go dead - about 5.5 hours per their website - the heater goes off.
I see that the power inverter isn't available for the larger Model 2400 and they recommend a 220 gallon fuel tank for the Model 2400.

The larger model - 2400 - will use about a gallon every three hours at the highest heat output setting. That's about 8 gallons a day, 240 gallons a month.
Note that the estimated fuel cost cited in their web site is based on 1993 fuel prices.heh heh heh
It mounts up over a whole heating season unless you live in southern Florida or southern California.

I prefer natural gas heat. Although the fuel cost may be a bit more than with kerosene or fuel oil, the convenience is well worth it.
I have a natural gas stove for the same reasons.



--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit upon his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin slitting throats."--H.L.Mencken
I suspect so, H.L.heh heh

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
SSW68
Member
 

Reged: 12/22/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: Ted] new
      #292123 - 12/22/06 11:34 AM

Hi all. Just found this site after reading about the EdenPure heater and wanting more info. Glad you guys set me straight on that before I spent the $$$. I'm really just looking for a small portable heater to help heat the downstairs of my 2 story house during the winter. I've got a Homles Quartz tower heater that I use right now just to help out my drafty family room. My main idea is to help heat the downstairs and try to keep the power bills down. My gas furnace works fine, and the house is always comfortable, but I didn't know if I used a portable heater more if that would actually help on the power bills since the furnace wouldn't run so much. The upstairs is always fine.

We have a wood burning fireplace that previous owners had put in after the house was built and it was a crappy job. So much that I refuse to use it because it doesn't vent well. It has a gas starter and I didn't know if I'd be best off having a gas log installed.

Also, if I go the portable non-gas heater route, it doesn't sound like there's really much difference in any of them. Seems they're all around 1500 watts and the worst in effeciency. Since I'm pretty ignorant about all this stuff, I look to your expert advice. Is one type truely better than another? What's the difference in a heater that says convection? I've not researched this much (as you can probably tell.)

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
courteousk9
Member
 

Reged: 12/26/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: Rep] new
      #292285 - 12/26/06 04:03 PM

I just wanted to thank everyone for their appraisal of the Edenpure heater. You've saved me a lot of headaches. I am looking to replace an old vented gas heater (which still runs with an old fashioned pilot light) that's in a basement bedroom and I thought this might be a good alternative. Now, not so much. I think I will continue my search for an updated, effecient and safe vented gas space heater. Again thanks. I, like others have said, saw the add and just googled "edenpure" to get a line on it and found this site. Glad I stopped by.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Rag
Member
 

Reged: 12/27/06
Posts: 3
Re: Heater [Re: courteousk9] new
      #292306 - 12/27/06 10:42 AM

Great forum. Since I've written off the Eden Pure system, I'm looking for something that will work. I have an all metal 50 x 50 aircraft hangar (12 ft ceiling and concrete pad) that has no heat. I'm looking for a method to warm the building to 50 degrees F. Since I store a fuel filled aircraft in it, I can't use traditional combustion heaters. What will this work in this environment? I'm in the Midwest and it gets to sub zero temps in the winter.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: Rag] new
      #292308 - 12/27/06 11:16 AM

Quote:

Great forum. Since I've written off the Eden Pure system, I'm looking for something that will work. I have an all metal 50 x 50 aircraft hangar (12 ft ceiling and concrete pad) that has no heat. I'm looking for a method to warm the building to 50 degrees F. Since I store a fuel filled aircraft in it, I can't use traditional combustion heaters. What will this work in this environment? I'm in the Midwest and it gets to sub zero temps in the winter.



Hi Rag, and welcome to the forums. WOW!! That's big! Traditionally, something that big would get it's own boiler system. Not to sure how far you want to go with this, but there are a couple of different heat exchangers that would work with either a steam system, steam to water exchange, or even electric. That would make for a HUGE electric bill though. Have a look around this site , or maybe Weil-McLain . No simple little room heater is going to be of much use at all with something THAT big, or at those temperatures. One big thing to do in any case is insulate like crazy, and when you're done, insulate some more!!
Al

--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire
Smileys
Don't take life so seriously. It isn't permanent!



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Rag
Member
 

Reged: 12/27/06
Posts: 3
Re: Heater [Re: GrandfatherClock] new
      #292309 - 12/27/06 11:39 AM

Thanks, regretfully, the hangar is leased, so I can't make any "improvements." I've thought about insulation, but without a heat source, there's not much to insulate in. I do have an electrical (120v) outlet, but that's it and no real ventilation other than poor door seals.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: Rag] new
      #292310 - 12/27/06 12:03 PM

Quote:

Thanks, regretfully, the hangar is leased, so I can't make any "improvements." I've thought about insulation, but without a heat source, there's not much to insulate in. I do have an electrical (120v) outlet, but that's it and no real ventilation other than poor door seals.



Ouch! A 120v anything is going to be just about worthless in those conditions. The best I could suggest would be a turbo style heater, but you would need something along the lines of this animal to do any good. 50 x 50 is 2500 sq', and this will do *up to* 4700, but that isn't including the height of 12', which is 4' larger than *normal*. Add to that that you've got a metal *skin*, and some VERY cold temperatures to deal with, and you'll likely need every bit of the 200,000 BTU that one puts out. I also don't know what the propane bill *might* be, or how often you would have to put on a new tank.(Whoops. 9-1/2 hours acording to what they've said. Maybe there is a bigger tank?) That would get expensive in a heartbeat I'd assume. Perhaps one of the smaller units will do if you only want to keep things a little above freezing?
Al

--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire
Smileys
Don't take life so seriously. It isn't permanent!



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
j0eSmith
Wilderness Aviator
 

Reged: 08/12/03
Posts: 336
Loc: BC Canada
Re: Heater [Re: Rag] new
      #292320 - 12/27/06 03:12 PM

Quote:

Great forum. Since I've written off the Eden Pure system, I'm looking for something that will work. I have an all metal 50 x 50 aircraft hangar (12 ft ceiling and concrete pad) that has no heat. I'm looking for a method to warm the building to 50 degrees F. Since I store a fuel filled aircraft in it, I can't use traditional combustion heaters. What will this work in this environment? I'm in the Midwest and it gets to sub zero temps in the winter.




What kind of aircraft are you storing? Depending on its size, it may be possible to get an old parachute or something similar to drape over it. Then an extension cord and a space heater with a thermostat to stick underneath would solve your cold weather problems.

--------------------
..and one more thing, under no circumstances should you ever, ever, do thi-

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Rag
Member
 

Reged: 12/27/06
Posts: 3
Re: Heater [Re: j0eSmith] new
      #292334 - 12/27/06 05:57 PM

It's a cessna 172. Nothing fancy, but I'm wary of a fire source or direct heat to the aircraft.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
BJR
Member
 

Reged: 12/30/06
Posts: 4
Re: Heater [Re: Rag] new
      #292501 - 12/30/06 01:31 PM

So it would be a good guess that most of the regulars here LOVE the show Myth Busters.
I do.
Nothing but facts there.
That's what brought me here. Google searching for info regarding the biotech heater info that aparently everyone has received. I wanted to know more, now I do.
Threw that package away. Glad I researched.

Still I'm undecide what would be the most effecient to heat for me.

Oil heaters have been a clasic standby for several years, but they only heat a smaller or individual space. But they are dependable,
IF
one doesnt have a power failure.

I remember seeing in the back of popular mechanics, an ad for an outdoor, auger fed, pellet heater, whith a short blurb about it's efficiency.
I know this isn't much information about it but I can't seem to locate a PM around the house right now.

I like the idea of the pellets, as a conservationist at heart, because they are pressed sawdust left over from wood industry.
Auger fed with an extra capacity hopper.

This sparked interest after investigating auger fed pit smokers this summer. Constant heat without the feeding maintenance.

Anyone hear of these type of house heaters?

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
DazednConfused
Member
 

Reged: 12/31/06
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: SSW68] new
      #292558 - 12/31/06 04:56 PM

Unfortunately I DIDN'T find this site before I purchased a SunTwin "portable" heater. But to be perfectly honest, I think it did heat better than a ceramic heater, but that was before my 'bulbs' stopped working. I would like something better to heat my home (or least part of it) without having to replace my oil furnace which actually should be replaced. As I'm sure with a lot of people, money is extremely tight. Ummm...maybe some day.
Has anyone heard of a way to attach another heat source, such as a pellet furnace, to your existing furnace (oil)? In other words, being able to use either oil or pellets to heat the water for heat (oil hot water).
Sorry if I'm off track with any of this, I'm new to forums, uh...sorry..."communities".

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
david8866
Member
 

Reged: 01/01/07
Posts: 2
Re: Heater [Re: DazednConfused] new
      #292588 - 01/01/07 01:00 PM

May I suggest Micathermic heater.
We don't like regular portable heaters, they are noisy and drying. Last year we moved in an old house, although this house has electric central heater, the bill was a shocking $300 - and we only kept it at 64 F. We tried 6 Micathermic heater (from Bionaire and Soleus), the salesman promised we can return them within 30 days, or any time for next 2 years if we bought warranty $10 per piece. We tried. Two months now, our bill is still $300, but room temperature is 70/72 F.

We are happy, so we begin to look into other new "toys". Thanks guys, we were going to try Edenpure, so glad we find this place first.

Edited by david8866 (01/01/07 01:03 PM)

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: david8866] new
      #292592 - 01/01/07 01:54 PM

Quote:

May I suggest Micathermic heater.
We don't like regular portable heaters, they are noisy and drying. Last year we moved in an old house, although this house has electric central heater, the bill was a shocking $300 - and we only kept it at 64 F. We tried 6 Micathermic heater (from Bionaire and Soleus), the salesman promised we can return them within 30 days, or any time for next 2 years if we bought warranty $10 per piece. We tried. Two months now, our bill is still $300, but room temperature is 70/72 F.

We are happy, so we begin to look into other new "toys". Thanks guys, we were going to try Edenpure, so glad we find this place first.




Hi, David,

Welcome to the Forums!

Please do take this the wrong way - it's not meant to be condesending in the least, OK? But I feel you must not be aware that you have THE most expensive form of heating known to mankind. So it's little wonder that your power bill is so high. And while you did gain some heat by using the Micathermic heaters, you are still paying a HUGE penality in operating costs.

Natural gas is by far the least expensive means of heating where it's available. But even if it's not in your area, butane/propane or oil-fired furnaces rank a close second. Converting from your present electric bolier to any of those better alternatives isn't all that expensive and the amount you'd save on your power bill would cover the conversion costs in about two heating seasons. After that, you'll be saving an awful lot of money each month of the winter. Really! A very noticeable amount.

And there's still another bonus waiting for you if you change, though the operating cost savings is the big one. If you turn your heat down any at all during the night, the alternatives I suggested will warm the house back up much quicker in the morning! I believe you'd be truly amazed at the difference.

For a comparison, I'll use my own home which is really pretty large - about twice the size of the average home in the U.S. for a family of five. I live in the fairly high mountainous (you can read that as *very* cool due to altitude and exposure to winter winds) region of Northeast Georgia and we have to heat for a full four months every winter. It's rather sparsley populated (which is why I'm here) but that also means no natural gas. Instead, I use butane/propane and my heating bill is about $55/per month and the power bill is around $95 in the winter and $120 in the summer.

Just to total that for you, it's a combined $150 per month in the winter - half of what yours is.

--------------------
Light travels faster than sound; that's why people seem brighter - until you hear them.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: Old Dad] new
      #292612 - 01/01/07 09:23 PM

New one on me. Got a link? Nothing in Wiki, and google was like a train wreck. I don't sift well anymore. Looks like another Edenpure add campaign type of thing, but with even more *claims* and even less information. Clockhopper looking for help.
Al

--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire
Smileys
Don't take life so seriously. It isn't permanent!



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
david8866
Member
 

Reged: 01/01/07
Posts: 2
Re: Heater [Re: Old Dad] new
      #292614 - 01/01/07 10:17 PM

Old Dad, thank you. We have been thinking about gas heater. Beside we're slow on changing things, (according to neighbor) gas company wants a whopping $4000 on new gas line. We totally forgot other options: butane/propane or oil-fired furnaces. The house is L shape, one wing gets full sun, one wing gets almost none, so there are two central units - it will cost double to convert two units, but it is still better to do so. Really, really thank you, we have another possible options now.

Clockman, regarding Micathermic heaters, have you tried Amazon yet. There are a few. Here's one
DeLonghi's.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: GrandfatherClock] new
      #292616 - 01/01/07 10:47 PM

Quote:

New one on me. Got a link? Nothing in Wiki, and google was like a train wreck. I don't sift well anymore. Looks like another Edenpure add campaign type of thing, but with even more *claims* and even less information. Clockhopper looking for help.
Al




Hi, Al,

I just went to their website and browsed around. They talk about their 'special' heating elements but you and I (and many others) all know that that electric heat is still just electric heat. In terms of efficency it doesn't matter one bit if it's a nichrome coil, a light bulb, radiant heat lamp, quartz or what have you. One "BTU" of electricity is going to produce *exactly* one BTU of heat - no more, no less regardless of the type of heater or what it's housed in. (The only exception, of course is a heat pump but we've been talking about nothing here other than simple resistance heating.) Naturally there are safety issues involved in different models but the operating principle is totally identical in all of them - regardless of all the hype the different makers put out. (You could wrap up a horse in bearskin and paint stripes on it. But underneath all that fakery, it's still nothing more than just a horse.)

--------------------
Light travels faster than sound; that's why people seem brighter - until you hear them.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: david8866] new
      #292617 - 01/01/07 11:03 PM

Quote:

Old Dad, thank you. We have been thinking about gas heater. Beside we're slow on changing things, (according to neighbor) gas company wants a whopping $4000 on new gas line. We totally forgot other options: butane/propane or oil-fired furnaces. The house is L shape, one wing gets full sun, one wing gets almost none, so there are two central units - it will cost double to convert two units, but it is still better to do so. Really, really thank you, we have another possible options now.

Clockman, regarding Micathermic heaters, have you tried Amazon yet. There are a few. Here's one
DeLonghi's.




Hi again, David,

I'm really glad you took my post in the spirit that it was intended. Once in a while someone seems to be offended if they feel someone else is "talking down to them." I'm happy that you took it the right way.

Since we've not seen you before, I was uncertain about your age and experience with these sorts of things. The Madison Avenue ad-writers know how to make almost anything look good. I'm fortunate enough to have been around for a while (60+ years) and have seen every type of heating system under the sun. Either in a house I've bought (moved around a great deal) or a friend's home.

After learning more about your particular situation, I'd suggest you change out the systems one at a time. Begin with the one that heats the part of the home you use the most. And considering that when the whole thing is done you should be saving around $150 per month (possibly more) each heating season, it shouldn't take long to quickly pay for the job.

Also, here's another thought: considering what you'll be saving, it would be worth it to most people to even take out a loan and do both systems at once. I believe you'll find that what you'll save on the power bill will more than make your payments on the loan.

--------------------
Light travels faster than sound; that's why people seem brighter - until you hear them.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: david8866] new
      #292624 - 01/02/07 07:15 AM

Quote:

Old Dad, thank you. We have been thinking about gas heater. Beside we're slow on changing things, (according to neighbor) gas company wants a whopping $4000 on new gas line. We totally forgot other options: butane/propane or oil-fired furnaces. The house is L shape, one wing gets full sun, one wing gets almost none, so there are two central units - it will cost double to convert two units, but it is still better to do so. Really, really thank you, we have another possible options now.

Clockman, regarding Micathermic heaters, have you tried Amazon yet. There are a few. Here's one
DeLonghi's.



Thanks David. I found lots of information about where to get them and all the advertising claims, but was looking for the 'how it's made' and why it's 'so much better' type of *stuff* (read *hype* ) that was in Old Dad's link. Though there wasn't any REAL explanation of how they actually create heat (in the form of backing up their claims), there was enough to read between the lines with and determine it's all in the advertising (as usual). I just hadn't heard the term "Micathermic" before. As has been pointed out so many times in this thread, electrical resistance heating is the same no matter how you package it. You can add bells and whistles till the cows come home, but all you'll get is a more expensive, noisy heater, that attracts cows.
Al

--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire
Smileys
Don't take life so seriously. It isn't permanent!



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
nhgranite
Member
 

Reged: 01/02/07
Posts: 21
Re: Heater [Re: Old Dad] new
      #292633 - 01/02/07 04:05 PM

Thanks for all the good info on this site as pertains Eden Pure and all the rest. Up here in NH we pay 2.20/gal for oil or $1.26 for natural gas per therm, and we're still paying through our electric bill for a nuclear reactor that didn't go on line in the 70's, and is owned by the current electric company (called "stranded recovery"). That boosts our electric bill by about 25 per cent. I have burned wood, some free and some paid for (was $99/cord, now $250.) I coupled the wood stove with a natural gas hot air furnace, and close the rooms that aren't used. Gas dryer, stove, water heater, and furnace still brings the bill to (last month-December) $120. We own a "dutch colonial", maybe 100 years old, and the insulation isn't the latest, though I have 12 inches in the ceiling, exposed to the cold attic. I'm looking for comments on possibly switching from the wood stove to gas or pellets. The wood stove is currently in the cellar. It is a 500 pound Vermont Castings Defiant, takes a 20 inch log. The heat rises through cellar door to kitchen, and through a hole with a fan above the stove into the kitchen upstairs and throughout the house. On really cold days zero or below, it helps alot. On 32 degree days I don't have to use the gas furnace, but use the fan to push the air around and the house is 70 degrees. I no longer relish stacking 8 cords of wood outside to dry and throwing two cords downstairs to stack. I am 60 and just retired from public works. Used to get alot of free wood through work, but now have to pay like everybody else. Any comments on pellet or gas stove? Thanks.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
montanaroma
Member
 

Reged: 01/03/07
Posts: 1
Re: Heater [Re: nhgranite] new
      #292683 - 01/03/07 05:13 PM

I am so glad I stumbled onto this thread!
We were contemplating getting one of the Eden Pure heaters but after this we are back to plan A....
We live in a 1000 sq foot home and have all wood or tile floors with an unfinished full basement. We plan to install the radiant floor heat with a water boiler to heat it. What does everybody think of that? Will the radiant floor heat dry out our original oak flooring? It will be extremely easy to install because the upstairs floor is open from the basement. I was also wondering about using one of those (um-the name escapes me) the water heater promoted by Paul Harvey that heats the water as you use it thing! haha
I would do more research before I bought one - so I could at least remember the name! I would like to hear peoples thoughts on this type of heating-thanks in advance!

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Gox
The kids are back in school!
 

Reged: 07/28/03
Posts: 4639
Loc: Boise, Idaho USA
Re: Heater [Re: montanaroma] new
      #292689 - 01/03/07 06:34 PM

Can you plug a heater into a regular 110 volt outlet and draw 1500 watts safely?

M.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: montanaroma] new
      #292692 - 01/03/07 07:54 PM

Quote:

I am so glad I stumbled onto this thread!
We were contemplating getting one of the Eden Pure heaters but after this we are back to plan A....
We live in a 1000 sq foot home and have all wood or tile floors with an unfinished full basement. We plan to install the radiant floor heat with a water boiler to heat it. What does everybody think of that? Will the radiant floor heat dry out our original oak flooring? It will be extremely easy to install because the upstairs floor is open from the basement.



Hi montanaroma, and welcome to the forums.
A friend of mine has done EXACTLY what you are suggesting here, and hasn't had a problem at all. He did however, do quite a bit of *homework* before he chose the system he installed. If you check back after this weekend, I'll ask him about it and pass on any information I find. I do know that it's concidered one of the most comfortable heating systems available, and isn't all that hard to install, even from the underside as you wish to. That's what my friend did after having installed the same type of system in an addition from the top side. He and his wife liked it so much, he did some of the older sections of the house with it.
Quote:

I was also wondering about using one of those (um-the name escapes me) the water heater promoted by Paul Harvey that heats the water as you use it thing! haha



I don't know which one Mr. Harvey is promoting, but it's called a *point of use* heater. The tankless water heaters are also a good option if you presently have either natural gas or propane. The electric versions of them, though good at saving money *in use*, tend to be a bit pricey still. OK, a LOT pricey. Search google for the name of the point of use heater you're interested in, and let us know. That's a subject I wouldn't mind doing a little *legwork* for you with.
Quote:

I would do more research before I bought one - so I could at least remember the name! I would like to hear peoples thoughts on this type of heating-thanks in advance!



MHO is that they are *in general* very good. I too, would do some research before choosing one particular brand though. It boils down to price vs payback time as far as I know, and different brands may well have different payback times.
Al

--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire
Smileys
Don't take life so seriously. It isn't permanent!



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: Gox] new
      #292693 - 01/03/07 08:30 PM

Quote:

Can you plug a heater into a regular 110 volt outlet and draw 1500 watts safely?

M.




Hi, Maggie,

Generally, yes. That's because the outlet is normally fused with a 30-amp breaker (which is perfectly safe for home use) and your heater would only be pulling half of that. Only in *VERY* rare cases would you also have an additional 15 amp load on that same identical circuit. And even then, you'd only have "nuisance" tripping of the breaker rather than an actual safety issue.

The only normal problem one might encounter - and it's still not a safety issue - is if the circuit is fed by a GFCI since in household applications is all too commonly a 20-amp unit. Again, just a possibility of annoying breaker tripping.

--------------------
Light travels faster than sound; that's why people seem brighter - until you hear them.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
GrandfatherClock
Half a bubble off
 

Reged: 07/23/03
Posts: 10340
Loc: Wallyworld, CT
Re: Heater [Re: Old Dad] new
      #292694 - 01/03/07 08:55 PM

Quote:

Hi, Maggie,

Generally, yes. That's because the outlet is normally fused with a 30-amp breaker (which is perfectly safe for home use) and your heater would only be pulling half of that.



Wanna look a little closer on that Odie one? Are you saying you have *mostly* 30a circuits at home?
Quote:

Only in *VERY* rare cases would you also have an additional 15 amp load on that same identical circuit. And even then, you'd only have "nuisance" tripping of the breaker rather than an actual safety issue.

The only normal problem one might encounter - and it's still not a safety issue - is if the circuit is fed by a GFCI since in household applications is all too commonly a 20-amp unit. Again, just a possibility of annoying breaker tripping.



I absolutely agree with this, but a 30a circuit as *the norm*? Most home circuits, especially in houses over 10 years old, were 15a - or LESS on some from our era.
Al


--------------------
Common sense is not so common
Voltaire
Smileys
Don't take life so seriously. It isn't permanent!



Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Old DadAdministrator
HWW's Own Jerry-Atric
 

Reged: 02/20/03
Posts: 9205
Re: Heater [Re: GrandfatherClock] new
      #292695 - 01/03/07 09:13 PM

Quote:

Wanna look a little closer on that Odie one? Are you saying you have *mostly* 30a circuits at home?

I absolutely agree with this, but a 30a circuit as *the norm*? Most home circuits, especially in houses over 10 years old, were 15a - or LESS on some from our era.
Al




Ack!! Please pardon this old geezer while he goes and has 15 (or 30) neurons quickly replaced!

Yes, 15 amps IS absolutely the norm! I should know better, especially since I've installed *dozens* of the things.

And that brings us to this point - the heater *should* work in most cases but can trip the breaker pretty easily if the breaker has a little age on it. Even new ones can be a bit weak but it becomes more common as they age (like me, I guess).

--------------------
Light travels faster than sound; that's why people seem brighter - until you hear them.

Post Extras: